Deathtouch vs Indestructible MTG: Which Wins? (2026)

Deathtouch doesn't kill indestructible creatures: deathtouch damage makes the game destroy a creature, and indestructible can't be destroyed. Rules and edge cases.

Shon Atsil6 min readMagic
Five MTG cards fanned on a dark background: Baleful Strix, Typhoid Rats, Darksteel Colossus in the centre, Avacyn, Angel of Hope and Ohran Frostfang

Quick verdict

Indestructible wins. Deathtouch doesn't kill anything by itself: a creature dealt damage by a deathtouch source is destroyed as a state-based action (CR 702.2b, 704.5h), and a permanent with indestructible can't be destroyed (CR 702.12b). The damage is still marked on the creature until end of turn, but the deathtouch check only looks at damage dealt since state-based actions were last checked, so removing indestructible later that turn won't bring the deathtouch back. To kill an indestructible creature, use exile, sacrifice, -X/-X, or strip indestructible before the damage is dealt.

No, deathtouch does not kill indestructible creatures. Deathtouch never kills anything directly. When a deathtouch source deals damage to a creature, the game destroys that creature as a state-based action (CR 702.2b, 704.5h). Indestructible means the permanent can't be destroyed (CR 702.12b). Deathtouch only ever leads to "destroy", and indestructible is the ability that ignores it, so indestructible wins every time.

If you want each keyword on its own first, see what deathtouch means and indestructible in MTG. This page is about the two meeting.

The rules

From the Comprehensive Rules effective 6 November 2026:

  • CR 702.2b: "A creature with toughness greater than 0 that's been dealt damage by a source with deathtouch since the last time state-based actions were checked is destroyed as a state-based action."
  • CR 704.5h: the same check, listed among the state-based actions. "Regeneration can replace this event."
  • CR 702.12b: "A permanent with indestructible can't be destroyed. Such permanents aren't destroyed by lethal damage, and they ignore the state-based action that checks for lethal damage."
  • CR 701.8b: a permanent can only be destroyed by an effect that says "destroy" or by the lethal-damage and deathtouch state-based actions.

The damage is still dealt and still marked on the indestructible creature (CR 120.3e). It just doesn't do anything.

Deathtouch vs indestructible side by side

DeathtouchIndestructible
Kind of abilityStatic (702.2a)Static (702.12a)
What it doesAny damage it deals to a creature gets that creature destroyedThe permanent can't be destroyed
Works onCreatures it deals damage to, in or out of combatThe permanent that has it
BeatsBig creatures without indestructible or regeneration"Destroy" spells, lethal damage, deathtouch
Loses toIndestructible, regeneration, damage prevention, being killed firstExile, sacrifice, -X/-X, bounce, losing indestructible
Typhoid Rats blocks Darksteel ColossusRats dieColossus survives

The classic example: Typhoid Rats vs Darksteel Colossus

Darksteel Colossus is an 11/11 with trample and indestructible. Typhoid Rats is a 1/1 with deathtouch. The Colossus attacks and the Rats block.

  1. The Colossus assigns 1 damage to the Rats (lethal for a 1-toughness creature) and tramples 10 over to the player.
  2. The Rats deal 1 damage to the Colossus.
  3. State-based actions: the Rats have lethal damage and are destroyed. The Colossus was dealt deathtouch damage, but it can't be destroyed, so nothing happens.

The same is true of Baleful Strix blocking anything that Avacyn, Angel of Hope protects. Avacyn has indestructible and gives it to every other permanent you control, so a deathtouch blocker trades with nothing.

Edge cases

Deathtouch damage doesn't wait for indestructible to go away

This is the one most players get wrong. The deathtouch check only counts damage dealt "since the last time state-based actions were checked" (CR 704.5h). State-based actions are checked right after combat damage, before anyone can act. At that moment the creature is still indestructible, so the deathtouch moment passes.

The damage stays marked until the cleanup step, though. If the marked damage is equal to or more than the creature's toughness, it dies to ordinary lethal damage (CR 704.5g) as soon as it loses indestructible. Scryfall's rulings for Shadowspear and Avacyn, Angel of Hope both describe this.

So 1 deathtouch damage on Darksteel Colossus does nothing even if it loses indestructible later. 11 damage would kill it the moment indestructible goes.

The fix: remove indestructible before the damage, not after. Shadowspear reads "{1}: Permanents your opponents control lose hexproof and indestructible until end of turn." Activate it before combat damage or before your fight spell resolves, and deathtouch kills normally.

Deathtouch plus trample

With deathtouch, any nonzero damage counts as lethal damage when you assign trample damage (CR 702.2c, 702.19b). That still works against an indestructible blocker: you assign 1 to it and the rest to the player. The blocker survives.

Example: Ohran Frostfang gives your attacking creatures deathtouch. If Darksteel Colossus attacks with it out and Avacyn blocks, you can assign 1 damage to Avacyn and 10 to the player. Avacyn survives. See how trample works for the full assignment rules.

Deathtouch plus first strike

Glissa, the Traitor has first strike and deathtouch, which normally means any blocker dies before it can deal damage back. Against an indestructible creature that plan fails. Glissa deals her first-strike damage, the blocker survives, and then it deals its damage in the regular combat damage step. A 3/3 Glissa blocked by an 8/8 Avacyn dies. More on the two damage steps in first strike and double strike.

Fight

In a fight, each creature deals damage equal to its power to the other (CR 701.14a). Cast Prey Upon to have Typhoid Rats fight Darksteel Colossus and the Rats deal 1 deathtouch damage (ignored) while the Colossus deals 11 back. The Rats die. Strip indestructible first and the fight kills the Colossus, although Darksteel Colossus then shuffles itself into its owner's library instead of going to the graveyard.

What still kills an indestructible creature

None of these use the word "destroy", so indestructible doesn't stop them:

  • -X/-X. A creature with toughness 0 or less goes to the graveyard (CR 704.5f). Toxic Deluge gives all creatures -X/-X.
  • Exile. Swords to Plowshares and Path to Exile.
  • Sacrifice. Liliana's Triumph makes each opponent sacrifice a creature of their choice.
  • The legend rule, which puts the extra legend into the graveyard rather than destroying it.

How to beat each one

Beating deathtouch:

  1. Give your creature indestructible, or a regeneration shield (regeneration replaces the deathtouch destruction).
  2. Prevent the damage. Protection from the deathtouch creature's colour does this.
  3. Kill it first. Many deathtouch creatures are small (79 of the 349 on Scryfall have 1 toughness), so first strike or a 1-damage effect like Pestilence handles those.

Beating indestructible:

  1. Exile, sacrifice or -X/-X.
  2. Remove indestructible before damage with Shadowspear, then attack or fight with deathtouch.
  3. Chump block with a deathtouch creature only when you want the trade to buy time. It won't kill the attacker.

The cards in this article

CardKeywordCheapest printing (Scryfall, 19 November 2026)
Typhoid RatsDeathtouch, 1/1 for {B}$0.21 (Innistrad or Fate Reforged)
Baleful StrixFlying, deathtouch, draws a card$4.83 (Final Fantasy Commander)
Ohran FrostfangGives your attackers deathtouch$6.82 (Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander)
Darksteel ColossusTrample, indestructible, 11/11$0.91 (Foundations)
Avacyn, Angel of HopeIndestructible, gives it to your other permanents$42.49 (Innistrad Remastered)

Prices are Scryfall's nonfoil USD for the cheapest regular printing of each card (The List, Secret Lair-style boxes and promos left out) and change daily.

The bottom line

Deathtouch turns any damage into "destroy". Indestructible ignores "destroy". When they meet, indestructible wins, and the damage left behind only matters if it was lethal in its own right. To kill an indestructible creature, don't reach for deathtouch; reach for exile, sacrifice or -X/-X.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions