Investigate MTG: Clue Token Rules and Best Cards (2026)

Investigate in MTG means create a Clue token: an artifact with {2}, sacrifice it: draw a card. Clue rules, collect evidence, payoffs and the best commanders.

Shon Atsil11 min readMagic
MTG investigate cards fanned out on a dark background: the Star Trek Commander Tireless Tracker in the center, Thraben Inspector and Lonis, Cryptozoologist on the left, Morska, Undersea Sleuth and Academy Manufactor on the right

Quick verdict

Investigate means "create a Clue token" (Comprehensive Rules 701.16a). A Clue is a colorless artifact token with "{2}, Sacrifice this token: Draw a card", so every investigate is a card you can draw later for two mana. Clues don't tap, so you can crack several in one turn at instant speed. The mechanic started in Shadows over Innistrad (April 2016) and came back in force in Murders at Karlov Manor (February 2024), next to collect evidence and suspect. On 19 November 2026, 141 paper cards investigate. The best Clue commander is Morska, Undersea Sleuth (8,046 EDHREC decks, 720 tagged Clues), and the most-played payoffs are Academy Manufactor and Tireless Tracker.

Investigate in MTG means "create a Clue token." A Clue token is a colorless artifact with "{2}, Sacrifice this token: Draw a card," so every time you investigate you bank one card that you can draw later for two mana. Clues don't tap, so you can crack as many as you can pay for, at instant speed. Investigate started in Shadows over Innistrad in 2016 and returned as a headline mechanic in Murders at Karlov Manor in 2024. On 19 November 2026, Scryfall lists 141 paper cards that investigate.

The whole mechanic is two lines in the Comprehensive Rules (effective 6 November 2026):

701.16a "Investigate" means "Create a Clue token." See rule 111.10f.

111.10f A Clue token is a colorless Clue artifact token with "{2}, Sacrifice this token: Draw a card."

How Investigate Works in MTG

When a card tells you to investigate, you create one Clue token. "Investigate twice" or "investigate X times" creates that many. The Clue sits on the battlefield until you want the card.

Thraben Inspector is the cleanest example:

When this creature enters, investigate. (Create a Clue token. It's an artifact with "{2}, Sacrifice this token: Draw a card.")

You pay {W} for a 1/2, and later you pay {2} for the card. The Inspector costs one mana up front and replaces itself, which is why cheap investigate creatures show up in so many decks.

To draw from a Clue:

  1. Pay {2}.
  2. Sacrifice the Clue. It goes to the graveyard for a moment, then stops existing, like any token.
  3. The ability goes on the stack. When it resolves, you draw a card.

It isn't a mana ability, so opponents can respond. They can't stop the draw by destroying the Clue at that point, though: you already sacrificed it as a cost.

Clue factWhat it means in play
Colorless artifact tokenCounts for artifact synergies; dies to artifact removal
Cost: {2} and sacrifice, no tapCrack it the turn you make it, crack several per turn, crack a tapped one
No timing restrictionDraw at instant speed, usually at the end of an opponent's turn
Uses the stackNot a mana ability; players can respond before you draw
Clue is an artifact typeAny Clue artifact counts, not only Clue tokens

Clue Token Rules and Edge Cases

These come from the Comprehensive Rules and Scryfall's official rulings on Tireless Tracker, Academy Manufactor, Teysa and other Clue cards.

"Clue" means any Clue artifact. Clue is an artifact type, never a creature type. Wrench from Murders at Karlov Manor is an Artifact — Clue Equipment with its own "{2}, Sacrifice this Equipment: Draw a card", so you can sacrifice it to pay for Alquist Proft, Master Sleuth's ability like any Clue token, and sacrificing it still triggers Tireless Tracker. Tangletrove Kelp is an Artifact Creature — Clue Plant.

"Whenever you sacrifice a Clue" triggers for any reason. Sacrifice it to draw, to Lonis, Cryptozoologist's ability, or to Krenko, Baron of Tin Street's "sacrifice an artifact" cost, and Tireless Tracker still gets its counter.

One Clue pays one cost. You can't sacrifice a single Clue to activate its own draw ability and Alquist Proft's ability at the same time.

Creating a Clue isn't always investigating. Academy Manufactor turns "create a Clue" into "create a Clue, a Food and a Treasure." Scryfall's ruling says those extra Clues are not an investigate, so "whenever you investigate" abilities such as Erdwal Illuminator's don't trigger for them. If the original Clue came from investigating once, those abilities trigger once, however many Clues you end up with.

Two Academy Manufactors triple it. With two, each Clue, Food or Treasure becomes three of each, not two. The ruling works it out up to eighteen Manufactors.

Targets can cost you the Clue. If a spell or ability that investigates has targets and they are all illegal when it resolves, it doesn't resolve, and you get no Clue.

Your opponent can investigate too. Fateful Absence destroys a creature or planeswalker and its controller investigates. That's the price of a two-mana instant answer: they get a card back for two mana.

Clues are not cards. They don't go to your hand, don't count as cards in hand for Wojek Investigator, and if an effect bounces or exiles one, it simply stops existing. Our MTG tokens guide covers the general token rules, and the stack guide covers why the draw can be responded to.

Where Investigate Came From: Shadows over Innistrad

Investigate debuted in Shadows over Innistrad, released 8 April 2016. The set's theme was a gothic mystery on Innistrad, and Clues were the flavour of characters searching for answers. Thraben Inspector, Tireless Tracker, Tamiyo's Journal, Ulvenwald Mysteries, Briarbridge Patrol, Fleeting Memories and Trail of Evidence are all from that set.

The mechanic came back in small doses after that:

  • Innistrad: Midnight Hunt (2021): Fateful Absence, and Secrets of the Key, which investigates twice when cast with flashback.
  • Modern Horizons 2 (2021): Hard Evidence (a 0/3 Crab and a Clue for {U}) and Lonis, Cryptozoologist.
  • Commander products: Thorough Investigation in Forgotten Realms Commander, Eloise, Nephalia Sleuth in Midnight Hunt Commander, Tivit, Seller of Secrets in New Capenna Commander.

Investigate in Murders at Karlov Manor

Murders at Karlov Manor, released 9 February 2024, built a whole set around detective work, with investigate as one of its main mechanics. It added Detective creatures, Clue artifacts that aren't tokens (Wrench), and two new keyword actions that sit next to investigate.

Collect evidence. "To collect evidence N means to exile any number of cards from your graveyard with total mana value N or greater" (rule 701.59a). It appears as an optional additional cost or as part of an ability. If your graveyard can't reach N, you can't choose to collect evidence at all. Analyze the Pollen is a {G} basic-land search that finds a creature or land instead if you collect evidence 8. Deadly Cover-Up is a board wipe that, with evidence 6 collected, also exiles a card from an opponent's graveyard and lets you hunt down and exile any copies of it from their graveyard, hand and library. Evidence Examiner ties the two mechanics together: whenever you collect evidence, investigate. Scryfall lists 22 paper cards with collect evidence.

Suspect. "Suspected" is a designation (rule 701.60). A suspected creature has menace and "This creature can't block" until it leaves the battlefield or an effect ends it. It isn't copiable, and suspecting an already suspected creature does nothing. Frantic Scapegoat suspects itself, then can pass the suspicion to another creature you control. Suspect has nothing to do with Clues; it is just the other half of the murder-mystery flavour.

Cases. Case of the Pilfered Proof is a Case enchantment that, once solved (three or more Detectives), adds a Clue to every batch of tokens you create.

The set's Commander decks added more. Morska, Undersea Sleuth, Tangletrove Kelp and Merchant of Truth were new there, and Tireless Tracker, Academy Manufactor, Lonis, Erdwal Illuminator, Ethereal Investigator, Disorder in the Court, Ongoing Investigation and Adrix and Nev were reprinted. Morska leads the Deep Clue Sea precon; see our Commander precons guide for how it compares with other decks.

Clue Payoffs: Cards That Reward Investigating

A pile of Clues is card draw on its own. Payoffs turn it into more. EDHREC tags 4,645 Commander decks with the Clues theme (19 November 2026), and these are the payoffs those decks play most. "Clue decks" is how many of the Clues-tagged decks that can play the card actually do.

  • Academy Manufactor

    What it does with Clues
    Each Clue, Food or Treasure you'd create becomes one of each
    In Clue decks
    3,531 of 4,645 (76%)
    Price
    $7.03

    {3}

    Cost

  • Tireless Tracker

    What it does with Clues
    Investigates on landfall; +1/+1 counter whenever you sacrifice a Clue
    In Clue decks
    2,026 of 2,564 (79%)
    Price
    $0.25

    {2}{G}

    Cost

  • Tamiyo's Journal

    What it does with Clues
    Investigates every upkeep; tap and sacrifice three Clues to tutor any card
    In Clue decks
    2,773 of 4,645 (60%)
    Price
    $0.61

    {5}

    Cost

  • Erdwal Illuminator

    What it does with Clues
    Your first investigate each turn makes an extra Clue
    In Clue decks
    2,473 of 4,072 (61%)
    Price
    $0.14

    {1}{U}

    Cost

  • Tangletrove Kelp

    What it does with Clues
    Your other Clues become 6/6 Plants each combat
    In Clue decks
    2,434 of 4,072 (60%)
    Price
    $0.41

    {5}{U}{U}

    Cost

  • Forensic Gadgeteer

    What it does with Clues
    Investigates on artifact spells; artifact abilities cost {1} less, so Clues cost {1}
    In Clue decks
    2,317 of 4,072 (57%)
    Price
    $2.35

    {2}{U}

    Cost

  • Adrix and Nev, Twincasters

    What it does with Clues
    Doubles every token you create, Clues included
    In Clue decks
    1,375 of 2,361 (58%)
    Price
    $6.53

    {2}{G}{U}

    Cost

  • Lonis, Cryptozoologist

    What it does with Clues
    Investigates when other nontoken creatures enter; sacrifice X Clues to steal a permanent off an opponent's library
    In Clue decks
    1,315 of 2,361 (56%)
    Price
    $0.28

    {G}{U}

    Cost

  • Ulvenwald Mysteries

    What it does with Clues
    Clue when a nontoken creature dies; 1/1 Soldier whenever you sacrifice a Clue
    In Clue decks
    1,151 of 2,564 (45%)
    Price
    $0.07

    {2}{G}

    Cost

  • Persuasive Interrogators

    What it does with Clues
    Two poison counters to an opponent whenever you sacrifice a Clue
    In Clue decks
    599 of 1,669 (36%)
    Price
    $0.21

    {4}{B}{B}

    Cost

Clue-deck counts from EDHREC's Clues theme page on 19 November 2026. Prices are the cheapest nonfoil printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026.

Academy Manufactor is the strongest payoff. Every investigate gives you a Clue, a Food and a Treasure, and the Treasure pays half the cost of cracking the Clue. It is also the priciest card here at $7.03.

Tireless Tracker is the classic Clue engine: a land a turn means a Clue a turn, and every Clue you crack makes it bigger. It was reprinted again in Star Trek Commander on 13 November 2026, and that printing is the cheapest at $0.25.

Forensic Gadgeteer makes each Clue cost only {1} to crack, since activated abilities of your artifacts cost {1} less (it can't reduce one below one mana).

The other payoffs reward sacrificing Clues rather than making them: Teysa, Opulent Oligarch makes a 1/1 flying Spirit when a Clue goes to the graveyard (once each turn), Ulvenwald Mysteries a 1/1 Soldier, Fleeting Memories mills three, Thorough Investigation ventures into the dungeon (see our venture guide), and Briarbridge Patrol lets you put a creature from your hand onto the battlefield at the end step if you sacrificed three or more Clues that turn.

Best Investigate Cards

Payoffs need Clues to work with. These are the investigate cards Clue decks play most, plus the cheap ones that do the job in any deck.

  • Ethereal Investigator ({3}{U}): a 2/3 flyer that investigates once for each opponent, three times in a four-player game, then makes a 1/1 flying Spirit whenever you draw your second card each turn. In 2,022 of 4,072 Clue decks.
  • Merchant of Truth ({2}{W}{W}): a 2/5 flyer that investigates whenever a nontoken creature you control dies, and gives your Clues exalted.
  • Disorder in the Court ({X}{W}{U}): exiles X creatures until the next end step, then investigates X times. Use it as a blink spell on your own creatures or to clear blockers.
  • Officious Interrogation ({W}{U}): investigates once for each creature the targeted players control. Target the player with the biggest board for a big batch of Clues.
  • Search the Premises ({3}{W}): a Clue whenever a creature attacks you or your planeswalkers. In multiplayer, people stop attacking you or pay you a card each time.
  • Deduce ({1}{U}): draw a card and investigate. A two-card cantrip at instant speed.
  • Wojek Investigator ({2}{W}): a 2/4 flying, vigilant Angel that investigates each upkeep for every opponent with more cards in hand than you.
  • Thraben Inspector and Novice Inspector ({W}): a 1/2 and a Clue for one mana.
  • Fateful Absence ({1}{W}): instant-speed removal for creatures and planeswalkers. The Clue goes to your opponent.
  • Confirm Suspicions ({3}{U}{U}): counter target spell and investigate three times.
  • Magnifying Glass ({3}): taps for {C}, or {4} and tap to investigate. Slow, but it works in any colour.

Best Investigate Commanders

  • 1.Morska, Undersea Sleuth

    Colours
    Green-white-blue
    EDHREC decks
    8,046 (#349)
    Tagged Clues
    720
    What it does
    Investigates every upkeep, no max hand size, grows on your second draw each turn

    $0.67

  • 2.Lonis, Cryptozoologist

    Colours
    Green-blue
    EDHREC decks
    5,118 (#606)
    Tagged Clues
    363
    What it does
    Clue when another nontoken creature enters; sacrifice Clues to steal from libraries

    $0.28

  • 3.Sophia, Dogged Detective

    Colours
    Green-white-blue
    EDHREC decks
    5,751 (#537)
    Tagged Clues
    314
    What it does
    Dogs that connect make a Food and a Clue

    $0.37

  • 4.Teysa, Opulent Oligarch

    Colours
    White-black
    EDHREC decks
    2,980 (#905)
    Tagged Clues
    195
    What it does
    Clue per opponent who lost life; Spirit when a Clue hits the graveyard

    $0.30

  • 5.Inquisitor Greyfax

    Colours
    White-blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    2,717 (#960)
    Tagged Clues
    139
    What it does
    Other creatures get +1/+0 and vigilance; pay {1} and tap to tap an opposing creature and investigate

    Foil only

  • 6.Tivit, Seller of Secrets

    Colours
    White-blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    13,070 (#177)
    Tagged Clues
    132
    What it does
    Votes for Clues or Treasures on entering and on combat damage

    $5.15

  • 7.Eloise, Nephalia Sleuth

    Colours
    Blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    1,494 (#1,386)
    Tagged Clues
    114
    What it does
    Clue when another creature you control dies; surveil 1 when you sacrifice a token

    $0.35

  • 8.Lazav, Wearer of Faces

    Colours
    Blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    1,394 (#1,440)
    Tagged Clues
    98
    What it does
    Exiles a graveyard card and investigates on attack; copies exiled creatures

    $0.21

  • 9.Ezrim, Agency Chief

    Colours
    White-blue
    EDHREC decks
    757 (#1,921)
    Tagged Clues
    97
    What it does
    5/5 flyer, two Clues on entering; sacrifice artifacts for vigilance, lifelink or hexproof

    $0.25

  • 10.Alquist Proft, Master Sleuth

    Colours
    White-blue
    EDHREC decks
    788 (#1,894)
    Tagged Clues
    88
    What it does
    Clue on entering; sacrifice a Clue to draw X and gain X life

    $0.28

How to read it. The order follows Tagged Clues: how many of the commander's decks EDHREC tags with the Clues theme on 19 November 2026. EDHREC decks is the commander's total, with its rank among all commanders. Most decks carry no theme tag, so the tagged number is well below the total. Price is the cheapest nonfoil printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026; Inquisitor Greyfax has no nonfoil price there.

Morska, Undersea Sleuth is the best Clue commander. It investigates every upkeep, so it is a free Clue a turn from the moment it lands, and cracking a Clue on your own turn is usually your second draw, which puts two +1/+1 counters on it. It has the most Clues-tagged decks by a wide margin (720), and its most-played cards are a Clue list: Academy Manufactor (6,532 of 8,046 decks), Tireless Tracker (6,217), Erdwal Illuminator (5,944), Adrix and Nev (5,790) and Tangletrove Kelp (5,751). It leads the Deep Clue Sea precon from Murders at Karlov Manor and costs $0.67 as a single.

Lonis, Cryptozoologist is the two-colour pick. Every nontoken creature you play brings a Clue, and its tap ability sacrifices X Clues to put a nonland permanent from an opponent's top X cards onto the battlefield under your control. Teysa, Opulent Oligarch is the aristocrats version. It investigates at your end step for each opponent who lost life that turn, and turns one Clue a turn into a 1/1 flying Spirit. Its decks pair it with Mirkwood Bats (2,391 of 2,980), which drains each opponent when you create or sacrifice a token, and Nadier's Nightblade (2,354), which drains when a token leaves the battlefield. Every Clue triggers both.

Tivit is the most-built of the ten but not a Clue deck. It leads 13,070 decks, yet only 132 are tagged Clues. EDHREC's top tags for it are Artifacts, Control, Combo and Extra Turns.

The table counts single commanders. The Doctor Who partner pair Jenny Flint and Madame Vastra has 207 Clues-tagged decks: Vastra makes a Clue and a Food when a creature it damaged dies, and Jenny Flint puts a +1/+1 counter on another creature whenever you sacrifice a Clue or Food.

Is Investigate Good?

A Clue is a card at a discount on timing, not on mana. You pay {2} for the draw, which is a fair rate, but you pay it whenever you have mana left over, usually at the end of an opponent's turn. That flexibility is the point: a deck with Clues rarely wastes mana.

Investigate is strongest when it rides on something the card already does. Thraben Inspector is a one-drop that replaces itself. Deduce is a cantrip with a second card attached. Tireless Tracker turns every land drop into a future card. When a card pays full price just to make a Clue, as Magnifying Glass does, it is slow.

In Commander, Clues have two extra uses. They are artifact tokens, so they feed sacrifice and artifact payoffs, and token doublers such as Adrix and Nev double them. The weakness is mana: a board of Clues with nothing to spend mana on is a hand you haven't drawn yet. For more keyword actions like investigate, explore and incubate, see our MTG keywords glossary.


Citations & Resources


Frequently Asked Questions