MTG Legacy vs Vintage: The Difference Explained (2026)

Legacy vs Vintage MTG: both allow almost every card, but Legacy bans the Power Nine while Vintage restricts 52 cards to one copy. Cost, proxies and MTGO.

Shon Atsil7 min readMagic
Black Lotus, Ancestral Recall, Brainstorm, Force of Will and Wasteland fanned on a dark background

Quick verdict

Legacy and Vintage are both eternal formats: decks can use cards from every Magic set. The difference is how each handles the most broken cards. Legacy bans them outright (73 named cards, including all of the Power Nine). Vintage bans only 3 named cards and restricts 52 others to a single copy, so Black Lotus, the Moxen and Ancestral Recall are legal. That makes Vintage the more powerful format and, in paper, far more expensive. Both are played on Magic Online, where the Power Nine costs a fraction of paper prices.

Legacy vs Vintage in MTG: both are eternal formats where decks can use cards from every Magic set. The difference is how each handles the most broken cards. Legacy bans them. Vintage restricts them to one copy per deck. So Black Lotus, Ancestral Recall and the Moxen are banned in Legacy but legal (one each) in Vintage, which makes Vintage the stronger format and, in paper, by far the more expensive one.

For where both sit among all the other formats, see the complete MTG formats guide.

Legacy vs Vintage side by side

Ban and restriction counts below are taken from Wizards' Banned & Restricted page on 19 November 2026.

LegacyVintage
Legal setsAll Magic setsAll Magic sets
Deck size60+ cards, up to 15 in sideboard60+ cards, up to 15 in sideboard
Copies per cardUp to 4 (basics unlimited)Up to 4, or 1 if restricted
Named banned cards733 (Chaos Orb, Falling Star, Shahrazad)
Restricted listNone52 cards
Power NineBannedRestricted (1 copy each)
Banned in bothConspiracy cards (25), ante cards (9), sticker and Attraction cards, offensive cardsSame
Proxies at sanctioned eventsNot allowedNot allowed
Magic OnlineYesYes
MTG ArenaNoNo (Timeless is the closest)
Paper cost driverReserved List dual lands and staplesPower Nine, Workshop, Bazaar, plus everything Legacy needs

"All Magic sets" has small exceptions: Wizards' 2026 Eternal Weekend announcement says the new-to-Magic cards in Mystery Booster Commander Edition aren't legal in Legacy or Vintage until 1 January 2027.

Banned vs restricted: how each format deals with broken cards

Banned means you can't play the card at all. Restricted means you can play one copy, counting main deck and sideboard together. Wizards' page says Vintage is the only format that uses a restricted list (MTG Arena's Timeless has its own, separate one).

Legacy's philosophy is to keep games interactive by removing the cards that end them too quickly. Vintage's is to let you play with nearly everything, but only one of each of the worst offenders, so you can't build a deck that does the same broken thing every game.

The result is that the two lists don't simply nest inside each other.

Banned in Legacy but fully legal in Vintage (33 cards). Some of these are the pillars of Vintage deckbuilding:

  • Mishra's Workshop: a land that taps for three mana for artifacts.
  • Bazaar of Baghdad: draw two, discard three, the engine of graveyard decks.
  • Mana Drain, Oath of Druids, Survival of the Fittest, Mind Twist.
  • Modern-era cards too: Oko, Thief of Crowns, Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer, Wrenn and Six, Psychic Frog, Grief, Entomb and Nadu, Winged Wisdom.

Restricted in Vintage but legal as four-ofs in Legacy (15 cards). These include Brainstorm, Lotus Petal, Lion's Eye Diamond, Chalice of the Void, Trinisphere, Urza's Saga, Karn, the Great Creator and Monastery Mentor. Brainstorm is the clearest example: it is the blue staple of Legacy, but next to Ancestral Recall and Time Walk it is one card too many.

The Power Nine: the line between the formats

The Power Nine are Black Lotus, Ancestral Recall, Time Walk, Timetwister and the five Moxen (Pearl, Sapphire, Jet, Ruby, Emerald). All nine are banned in Legacy and restricted in Vintage, and all nine are on the Reserved List, so they will never get a tournament-legal reprint. (Secrets of Strixhaven's Emeritus of Ideation has an Ancestral Recall spell on its back face, but it is a different card, off the Reserved List and legal in Legacy.) Our Black Lotus guide covers what the most famous of them does and what each printing sells for.

Because a Vintage deck runs one copy of each piece of Power, it opens with free mana or a broken draw spell much more often than a Legacy deck can. Legacy games tend to revolve around four-ofs like Brainstorm, Force of Will, Daze and Wasteland.

What each format costs

Both formats share the same problem: the Reserved List, Wizards' promise not to reprint certain old cards. That includes the ten original dual lands that many Legacy and Vintage decks use. Paper prices from Scryfall on 19 November 2026, cheapest printing of each:

CardFormat roleCheapest paper printing
Underground SeaDual land, both formats$1,099.49 (Revised)
Volcanic IslandDual land, both formats$1,008.22 (Revised)
Gaea's CradleLand, both formats$1,653.09 (Urza's Saga)
Force of WillFree counterspell, both formats$53.49 (Dominaria Remastered)
WastelandLand destruction, both formats$14.86 (Mystery Booster 2)
DazeFree counterspell, both formats$0.94 (Mystery Booster 2)
Bazaar of BaghdadVintage only (banned in Legacy)$2,400.00 (Arabian Nights)
Mishra's WorkshopVintage only (banned in Legacy)$3,925.00 (Antiquities)
Ancestral RecallVintage only (restricted)$4,999.95 (Unlimited)
Time WalkVintage only (restricted)$5,719.99 (Unlimited)

The rest of the Power Nine is pricier still. Scryfall shows no current USD price for a tournament-legal Black Lotus, which sells privately and at auction; Unlimited Moxen listed between $2,499.99 (Mox Ruby) and $3,513.33 (Mox Pearl), and an Unlimited Timetwister at $6,400.00. Force of Will and Wasteland are not on the Reserved List and have been reprinted, which is why they cost a fraction of the dual lands.

So a blue Legacy deck pays four figures per dual land. A full-power Vintage deck pays that, then adds the Power Nine and Workshop or Bazaar on top. For the bigger picture, see how much Magic: The Gathering costs and the most valuable MTG cards. For what the dual lands do, see our dual, fetch and shock lands guide.

Proxies: what the rules actually say

There is no Legacy or Vintage proxy exception in Wizards' rules.

  • Sanctioned events: Magic Tournament Rules section 3.4 says players can't create their own proxies. Only the head judge can issue one, mainly for a card that was accidentally damaged or excessively worn during that tournament (a foil with no non-foil printing also qualifies), and it is good for that tournament only. An expensive card doesn't qualify. Wizards' 2016 statement on proxies says cards in sanctioned events must be authentic.
  • Everything else: the same statement says Wizards has "no desire to police playtest cards made for personal, non-commercial use," even in a store. Unsanctioned events set their own proxy rules, so the event listing is the place to check.

Playing online: Magic Online

Both formats are supported on Magic Online (MTGO). The Power Nine came to MTGO in Vintage Masters (June 2014), and digital copies cost far less than paper. MTGO prices on Scryfall on 19 November 2026, in event tickets (tix), cheapest MTGO printing:

  • Black Lotus: 74.68 tix
  • Mox Pearl: 15.50 tix
  • Mox Sapphire: 8.45 tix
  • Ancestral Recall: 7.08 tix
  • Time Walk: 5.99 tix
  • Underground Sea: 16.60 tix

MTG Arena has neither format. Its nearest equivalent, Timeless, has its own banned and restricted list and doesn't include the Power Nine.

Legacy or Vintage: which should you play?

Play Legacy if you want the deepest eternal format that still has four-of deckbuilding, a wider range of decks, and an easier paper entry (many decks need duals but not Power).

Play Vintage if you want to cast Black Lotus and Ancestral Recall, you enjoy fast, high-variance games, and you either play on MTGO or have a group that plays unsanctioned with proxies.

Try both cheaply on Magic Online first, where a Black Lotus is about 75 tix instead of a five- or six-figure paper card. In paper, look for unsanctioned local events that state a proxy allowance.

If you want a non-rotating format with a lower ceiling, our Modern vs Standard comparison covers the other main constructed formats.

Where the top players meet: Eternal Weekend

Each Eternal Weekend hosts a Legacy Championship and a Vintage Championship, run by a local organizer and announced by Wizards on magic.gg. The 2026 schedule has three: Pittsburgh (29 October to 1 November, run by Pastimes), Tokyo (28 to 29 November, Hareruya) and Lucca, Italy (3 to 6 December, 4Seasons). Top 32 in the Vintage Championship get a retro-frame Treasure Cruise; the Legacy Championship's promo is Life from the Loam.

The bottom line

Legacy and Vintage share a card pool and differ in one rule: Legacy bans the broken cards, Vintage lets you play one of each. That one rule puts the Power Nine, Mishra's Workshop and Bazaar of Baghdad into Vintage, and pushes its paper cost well beyond Legacy's.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions