Brawl vs Commander MTG: Every Difference Explained (2026)

Brawl is Commander built for 1v1: 25 life, no commander damage, planeswalker commanders and a free mulligan. Arena's 100-card Brawl vs paper's 60-card rules.

Shon Atsil5 min readMagic
Five legendary commander cards fanned on a dark background: Kenrith, the Returned King in the centre, with Meren of Clan Nel Toth, Muldrotha, the Gravetide, Nissa, Who Shakes the World and Lathril, Blade of the Elves

The Short Answer

Brawl is Commander built for two players. Both formats use a legendary commander, one copy of each card except basic lands, and decks locked to the commander's colour identity. The differences: Brawl starts at 25 life instead of 40, has no commander damage, lets any legendary planeswalker be your commander, gives everyone a free first mulligan, and uses its own card pool and ban list.

Deck size depends on which Brawl you mean. Brawl on MTG Arena is 100 cards, the same as Commander. Standard Brawl on Arena and the paper rules (CR 903.12) are 60 cards.

What Is Brawl in MTG?

Brawl is officially an option of the Commander variant. CR 903.12a says Brawl games "use the normal rules for the Commander variant" with a handful of changes. So the command zone, colour identity and the {2} commander tax each time you recast your commander all work exactly as in Commander (EDH).

Wizards' own Brawl page calls it "most similar to Commander" and today describes only the Arena version: a 100-card deck led by "any legendary creature or Planeswalker from a set currently on Arena," 25 life, two players, "best of one, including a free mulligan."

The paper rules still live in the Comprehensive Rules (effective 6 November 2026):

  • CR 903.12b: Brawl decks are "usually constructed using cards from the Standard format."
  • CR 903.12c: your commander can be a legendary creature, planeswalker, Vehicle, or Spacecraft with a power/toughness box.
  • CR 903.12d: exactly 60 cards, including the commander.
  • CR 903.12f: 25 starting life in a two-player game, 30 in a multiplayer game.
  • CR 903.12g: the first mulligan in any Brawl game is free.
  • CR 903.12h: no 21 commander damage rule.

Brawl vs Commander: The Comparison Table

Arena renamed the 100-card format once called Historic Brawl to plain Brawl in December 2023 (mtg.wiki, citing Arena's patch notes). The original 60-card Standard version, which used to be called Brawl, is now Standard Brawl. Our Commander on MTG Arena guide covers the history in full.

  • Deck size

    Commander
    100
    Brawl (Arena)
    100
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    60
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    60
  • Players

    Commander
    Usually 4
    Brawl (Arena)
    2
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    2
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    2 or more
  • Starting life

    Commander
    40
    Brawl (Arena)
    25
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    25
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    25 (1v1), 30 (multiplayer)
  • Commander damage (21)

    Commander
    Yes
    Brawl (Arena)
    No
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    No
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    No
  • Planeswalker commanders

    Commander
    Only if the card says it can be your commander
    Brawl (Arena)
    Any legendary planeswalker
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    Any legendary planeswalker
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    Any legendary planeswalker
  • Free first mulligan

    Commander
    Multiplayer games only
    Brawl (Arena)
    Yes
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    Yes
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    Yes, every game
  • Card pool

    Commander
    Almost every card ever printed
    Brawl (Arena)
    Every card on Arena, Alchemy included
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    Standard-legal cards
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    Usually Standard
  • Ban list

    Commander
    42 named cards plus ante and Conspiracy cards
    Brawl (Arena)
    35 cards
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    No separate list
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    No separate list
  • Commander tax

    Commander
    {2} per previous cast
    Brawl (Arena)
    Same
    Standard Brawl (Arena)
    Same
    Brawl (paper, CR 903.12)
    Same

Sources: Comprehensive Rules 103.5c, 903.3, 903.5a, 903.7, 903.10a and 903.12 (6 November 2026); Wizards' Brawl format page and banned and restricted list, checked 19 November 2026.

The Differences That Change How You Play

25 life and no commander damage

Commander's 40 life exists because three opponents are attacking. In a 1v1 Brawl game, 25 life makes fast, aggressive commanders much stronger. And because CR 903.12h removes commander damage, a Voltron deck that would win in Commander by hitting someone with its commander for 21 has to deal the full 25 in Brawl.

Planeswalker commanders

In Commander, your commander has to be a legendary creature (or a legendary Vehicle or Spacecraft with power and toughness), unless the card says it can be your commander (CR 903.3, 903.3a). Teferi, Temporal Archmage has that line; most planeswalkers don't. Brawl lets any legendary planeswalker lead the deck. Nissa, Who Shakes the World is a legal Brawl commander on Scryfall, but in Commander she can only go in the 99.

The free mulligan

In any Brawl game, your first mulligan is free: you shuffle, draw a new seven and keep all seven (CR 103.5c, 903.12g). Commander gets the same free mulligan only in multiplayer games, so a 1v1 Commander game uses the normal London mulligan from the first redraw. Our mulligan rules guide walks through both. One exception on Arena: Competitive Brawl, the ranked queue launched on 23 June 2026, has "no free mulligan... like other ranked formats," according to Wizards' announcement.

Different ban lists

The two lists barely overlap. Brawl's 35 banned cards include fast mana, tutors and free spells that Commander allows, such as Ancient Tomb, Chrome Mox, Demonic Tutor, Force of Will and Fierce Guardianship, plus cards that shut down one commander, like Pithing Needle and Sorcerous Spyglass, and extra-turn spells like Time Warp. Commander's own list is 42 named cards plus every ante and Conspiracy card. Several of the cards Brawl bans are on Commander's Game Changers list instead.

Card pool

Commander can use almost any card from Magic's history. Brawl on Arena uses Arena's card pool, which includes digital-only Alchemy cards; Wizards' State of the Formats 2026 says those cards stay legal in Brawl after the Alchemy format leaves Arena on 2 February 2027. Standard Brawl is limited to Standard-legal cards, which makes it the cheapest version to build.

Colourless commanders

Brawl has one deckbuilding rule Commander doesn't. If your commander has no colours in its colour identity, CR 903.12e lets you play any number of basic lands of one basic land type of your choice. In Commander, a colourless deck can't run basic Plains, Islands, Swamps, Mountains or Forests at all, because each of them makes coloured mana (CR 903.5d), so it relies on Wastes and other colourless lands.

Competitive Brawl, Arena's ranked version

Competitive Brawl keeps Brawl's 100 cards and 25 life but drops the free mulligan, allows Vehicles and Spacecraft as commanders as well as legendary creatures and planeswalkers, and bans a short list of commanders rather than cards in the 99, according to Wizards' June 2026 announcement.

Where to Play Each Format

  • Commander: paper tables at almost every game store, SpellTable with your own cards on a webcam, and Magic Online. MTG Arena has no Commander mode as of November 2026.
  • Brawl: MTG Arena, which runs Brawl, Standard Brawl and Competitive Brawl. All three are 1v1 only.
  • Paper Brawl: legal under CR 903.12, but you'll need a group that agrees to play it.

If you're choosing between clients, our MTG Arena vs MTGO comparison covers which formats each one supports.

Brawl or Commander: Who Should Play Which?

Play Brawl if you want Commander-style deckbuilding in short 1v1 games, you play mostly on MTG Arena, or you're learning how commanders, colour identity and the command zone work. On Arena you need only one copy of each card, so a Brawl deck costs fewer wildcards per card than a Standard deck.

Play Commander if you want the four-player social game, deals and threat assessment included, you want to use cards from any era of Magic, or you want the format most game stores host on Commander nights. Our Magic formats guide shows where it fits with the rest.

Many players do both: build and test commander ideas in Brawl on Arena, then sleeve up the 100-card version for a paper pod.

Frequently Asked Questions

All guides