Quick verdict
Fear is an evasion ability: a creature with fear can't be blocked except by artifact creatures and/or black creatures. It was black's signature evasion from Alpha's Fear aura in 1993 until Wizards dropped it for Magic 2010 and replaced it with intimidate in Zendikar, which works on any colour. Intimidate was itself retired for menace in Magic Origins (2015). Fear is still in the Comprehensive Rules and every old fear card works as printed, so you still see it in Commander on cards like Shriekmaw, Cover of Darkness and Shizo, Death's Storehouse.
Fear in MTG is an evasion ability: a creature with fear can't be blocked except by artifact creatures and/or black creatures. If the defending player has no black creatures and no artifact creatures, your fear creature is unblockable. It was black's own evasion for most of the game's first two decades, until Wizards replaced it with intimidate in 2009, which was in turn replaced by menace in 2015.
The fear keyword is gone from new cards, but not from the game. It is still in the Comprehensive Rules, every old card with fear works as printed, and several of them are fixtures in Commander.
Fear Keyword Rules
Rule 702.36 of the Comprehensive Rules covers fear in three lines:
702.36a Fear is an evasion ability.
702.36b A creature with fear can't be blocked except by artifact creatures and/or black creatures.
702.36c Multiple instances of fear on the same creature are redundant.
That's the whole mechanic. What follows from it:
Any black creature can block it. That includes multicoloured creatures with black in them. A black-green creature is black, so it can block.
Any artifact creature can block it. Colour doesn't matter here. A blue artifact creature, a colourless Construct token or a Phyrexian artifact creature can all block a fear creature.
Everything else can't. A white, green or red creature that isn't an artifact can't block. Neither can a colourless creature that isn't an artifact, which covers most Eldrazi.
It only matters when blockers are declared. The restriction is checked as the defending player declares blockers. If a creature legally blocks and then loses black or stops being an artifact, it stays blocking.
It doesn't stop the fear creature from blocking. Fear only limits what can block it. A creature with fear blocks as normal.
Two instances do nothing extra. Giving a creature fear twice (say, Cover of Darkness plus Mask of Riddles) is the same as giving it fear once.
It stacks with other evasion. A creature with fear and menace can only be blocked by two or more creatures, each of which has to be black or an artifact. A creature with fear and flying needs a black or artifact blocker that also has flying or reach.
| Blocker | Can it block a creature with fear? |
|---|---|
| Black creature | Yes |
| Black-and-another-colour creature | Yes, it's black |
| Artifact creature of any colour | Yes |
| Colourless artifact creature (Construct, Golem) | Yes |
| Colourless non-artifact creature (most Eldrazi) | No |
| White, blue, red or green non-artifact creature | No |
Where Fear Came From and Why It Was Retired
The ability is as old as the game. Fear was a black Aura in Alpha (1993), and the keyword is named after it: the card's rules text is the ability. Today's Oracle text for that card reads "Enchanted creature has fear."
For years cards spelled it out. The original Odyssey printing of Shadowmage Infiltrator (2001) says "can't be blocked except by artifact creatures and/or black creatures" in full, while Champions of Kamigawa's Marrow-Gnawer (2004) just says "All Rats have fear." Fear stayed in black through Lorwyn, where Shriekmaw and Dread carry it, and the last regular-set cards with fear were printed in Alara Reborn in April 2009 (Jhessian Zombies and Lightning Reaver).
Mark Rosewater explained what happened next in his Zendikar Talk column (12 October 2009):
- The name was backwards. "The keyword fear always bugged the creative team because the adjective was backwards." A fear creature makes others afraid; it isn't scared itself.
- It was removed from Magic 2010. The core set team "made the call to remove fear from M10."
- It only worked in black. Rosewater: "I was frustrated that fear was a keyword we could only make use of in black."
The fix came in Zendikar (October 2009): intimidate. Rosewater again: "On a black creature, intimidate works exactly like fear except for one difference: Color changing effects now interact with it."
Wizards never changed old fear cards to intimidate in Oracle. Shriekmaw, Shadowmage Infiltrator and the rest still have fear, and they play by rule 702.36. The only brand-new fear card since 2009 is Wire Surgeons, a 6/5 from The Brothers' War Commander decks (2022).
Intimidate MTG: Fear's Replacement
Rule 702.13b: a creature with intimidate can't be blocked except by artifact creatures and/or creatures that share a colour with it.
The difference from fear is that intimidate looks at the attacker's own colours instead of always asking for black:
- A black creature with intimidate can be blocked by black and artifact creatures. Same as fear.
- A red creature with intimidate (Krenko's Enforcer) can only be blocked by red and artifact creatures.
- A green creature with intimidate (Bellowing Tanglewurm) can only be blocked by green and artifact creatures.
- A multicoloured creature with intimidate can be blocked by anything sharing any one of its colours.
- A colourless creature with intimidate shares no colour with anything, so only artifact creatures can block it.
The Scryfall rulings on Halo Hunter (Zendikar) add two details. Intimidate looks at the creature's current colours, so turning Halo Hunter white means only artifact and white creatures can block it. And colour only matters as blockers are declared: once it's blocked, changing its colour doesn't unblock it.
Intimidate lasted six years. Its last core-set appearance was Magic 2015 (Accursed Spirit, Krenko's Enforcer), and it still turns up in Commander on cards such as Vela the Night-Clad (Planechase 2012) and Mikaeus, the Unhallowed (Dark Ascension, 2012).
Fear vs Intimidate vs Menace
In his Evergreen Eggs & Ham column (8 June 2015), Rosewater explained why intimidate went too. "Evasion based on color ended up making it a very swingy mechanic," it "plays poorly with both multicolored environments and environments with a high colorless component," and "the mechanic has proved more confusing than we first thought." Menace, which "focuses on how many creatures need to block it," took over in Magic Origins.
The same problem applied to fear. Against a mono-black deck a fear creature is a vanilla creature; against a deck with no black and no artifacts it's unblockable.
Rule
- Fear
- 702.36
- Intimidate
- 702.13
- Menace
- 702.111
Who can block
- Fear
- Artifact and/or black creatures
- Intimidate
- Artifact creatures and/or creatures sharing a colour with it
- Menace
- Any creatures, but at least two
Depends on
- Fear
- The blocker's colour
- Intimidate
- The attacker's and blocker's colours
- Menace
- Number of blockers
Colours it appeared in
- Fear
- Almost all black; also colourless artifacts and a couple of oddities (Squealing Devil, Dust Elemental)
- Intimidate
- Any colour
- Menace
- Mostly black and red
Status
- Fear
- Retired 2009 (Magic 2010)
- Intimidate
- Retired 2015 (Magic Origins)
- Menace
- Evergreen
Worst matchup
- Fear
- Black decks
- Intimidate
- Decks in the same colour
- Menace
- Wide boards of tokens
Menace has its own guide: what menace means in Magic covers the two-blocker rule and how it combines with deathtouch and trample. For the rest of the evasion keywords, see the MTG keywords glossary.
Notable Fear Cards
Prices below are the cheapest regular printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026.
Shadowmage Infiltrator
- What it does
- 1/3 fear; draw a card when it deals combat damage to a player
- Price
- $0.27
1UB
Cost
Shriekmaw
- What it does
- Destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature; 3/2 fear body
- Price
- $0.22
4B (evoke 1B)
Cost
Dread
- What it does
- 6/6 fear; destroys any creature that damages you
- Price
- $8.44
3BBB
Cost
Avatar of Woe
- What it does
- 6/5 fear; tap to destroy a creature; costs 6 less with 10+ creatures in graveyards
- Price
- $3.96
6BB
Cost
Ratcatcher
- What it does
- 4/4 fear; tutors a Rat every upkeep
- Price
- $9.38
4BB
Cost
Wort, Boggart Auntie
- What it does
- 3/3 fear; returns a Goblin card from your graveyard each upkeep
- Price
- $28.72
2BR
Cost
Marrow-Gnawer
- What it does
- All Rats have fear; sacrifice a Rat to double your Rats
- Price
- $24.57
3BB
Cost
Cover of Darkness
- What it does
- Creatures of the chosen type have fear
- Price
- $8.31
1B
Cost
Shizo, Death's Storehouse
- What it does
- Taps for B; B, T: a legendary creature gains fear
- Price
- $31.86
Land
Cost
Profane Command
- What it does
- Modal; up to X creatures gain fear as a finisher
- Price
- $0.27
XBB
Cost
Shadowmage Infiltrator. The card most players picture when they hear "fear". An Odyssey rare that drew a card every time it connected, and against a deck without black creatures it connected every turn.
Shriekmaw. A removal spell first and a creature second. Its kill clause, "nonartifact, nonblack", mirrors fear exactly: it can't destroy the creatures that could block it. Evoke it for {1}{B} as a two-mana kill spell, or hard-cast it for removal plus an attacker. Our evoke guide covers how that alternative cost works.
Dread. The black Incarnation from Lorwyn: a 6/6 with fear that punishes any creature that damages you, and shuffles back into your library when it hits a graveyard.
Avatar of Woe. Repeatable creature removal on a fear body, and often cheap to cast in a long game.
Cover of Darkness. Two mana, one creature type, all of them with fear. It's the tribal version of the mechanic: Zombies, Rats or any type you name.
Shizo, Death's Storehouse. A land that taps for black and, for {B}, gives a legendary creature fear until end of turn. In Commander that usually means your commander.
Profane Command. Most modes are value, but "up to X target creatures gain fear" turns a board stall into lethal.
Cheaper commons and uncommons hand fear to a single creature: Aphotic Wisps (makes a creature black, gives it fear until end of turn and draws a card), Ebony Charm (fear until end of turn as one of its modes), and Mask of Riddles and Sleeper's Robe (fear for as long as they stay attached, plus a card when the creature connects).
Fear in Commander Today
Fear is weaker in a four-player game than in a duel, for a simple reason: many Commander decks run artifact creatures, and someone at the table is usually playing black.
What keeps fear useful:
- Only the defending player's creatures block. You pick who to attack. A fear creature attacking the green-white player with no artifact creatures is unblockable, even if the black player next to them has a full board.
- It's free on cards you play anyway. Nobody plays Shriekmaw for the fear. It's removal, and the evasion is a bonus.
- It suits commander damage. Shizo makes a legendary creature hard to block for one mana, which matters in decks trying to land 21 commander damage.
- It turns on combat-damage triggers. An unblocked fear creature can be swapped for a ninja; see how ninjutsu works.
On EDHREC on 19 November 2026, Shizo, Death's Storehouse was in 223,500 decks, Cover of Darkness in 112,139 and Shriekmaw in 104,407. Marrow-Gnawer, which gives all Rats fear, is the most-built Rat commander; see the best rat commanders for the full ranking.
Intimidate gets similar play. Mikaeus, the Unhallowed (in 121,987 EDHREC decks on the same date) is played for undying, not for its intimidate, and Vela the Night-Clad gives your whole team intimidate. For how these formats work, see the MTG formats guide.
Common Misconceptions
"Fear means only black creatures can block." Artifact creatures of any colour can block too.
"Fear was renamed intimidate, so old cards have intimidate." They don't. Old cards keep fear in Oracle text and follow the fear rules. On a non-black creature the two can be very different.
"Fear means unblockable." Only against a defending player with no black and no artifact creatures.
"A colourless creature can always block fear." Only if it's an artifact creature. Colourless alone isn't enough.
Frequently Asked Questions
Read next
All guides
MTG Annihilator: What It Does, Rules and Best Cards (2026)Annihilator N in MTG: whenever the creature attacks, the defending player sacrifices N permanents of their choice. Full rules, rulings and the best cards.Magic
Boast MTG: What It Means, Rules and Best Cards (2026)Boast in MTG is an activated ability you can use only if the creature attacked this turn, and only once each turn. Full boast rules, Birgi and the best cards.Magic
Changeling MTG: Rules, Kindred Cards and Best Changelings (2026)Changeling in MTG means a card is every creature type, in every zone. The changeling rules, kindred changelings, rulings and the best changelings for Commander.Magic

