Best Rat Commanders in MTG (2026), Ranked

Marrow-Gnawer leads 14,634 EDHREC decks, the most of any rat commander; Vren costs $0.71. The 12 best rat commanders ranked, with key cards (18 Nov 2026).

Shon Atsil13 min readMagic
Best rat commanders in MTG: Marrow-Gnawer in the centre, fanned with Vren, the Relentless, Karumonix, the Rat King, Wick, the Whorled Mind and Rat King, Verminister on a dark background

Our top 4 picks

Ranked. Pick one to read why, and what it costs.

  1. Top pick
    1

    Marrow-Gnawer

    The most-built rat commander, and the most expensive

    $24.57Scryfall, 18 November 2026

  2. 2

    Vren, the Relentless

    Best budget rat commander: nearly as popular as Marrow-Gnawer for under a dollar

    $0.71Scryfall, 18 November 2026

  3. 3

    Wick, the Whorled Mind

    The cheapest of the top three, and the commander most often tagged as a Rats deck

    $0.30Scryfall, 18 November 2026

  4. 4

    Karumonix, the Rat King

    The mono-black poison option

    $0.91Scryfall, 18 November 2026

Our picks

  1. Marrow-GnawerTop pick

    Marrow-Gnawer

    The most-built rat commander, and the most expensive

    • Pro: Leads 14,634 EDHREC decks (rank #143)
    • Pro: Gives every Rat fear and roughly doubles your Rats in one activation
    • Con: From $24.57 (borderless Bloomburrow Commander printing); the 2004 original is $31.87

    Price

    $24.57Scryfall, 18 November 2026

  2. Vren, the Relentless

    Vren, the Relentless

    Best budget rat commander: nearly as popular as Marrow-Gnawer for under a dollar

    • Pro: Leads 13,063 EDHREC decks (rank #178)
    • Pro: Turns every opposing creature that dies into a growing Rat token
    • Con: Needs creatures to die, so it leans on removal more than on Rats

    Price

    $0.71Scryfall, 18 November 2026

  3. Wick, the Whorled Mind

    Wick, the Whorled Mind

    The cheapest of the top three, and the commander most often tagged as a Rats deck

    • Pro: Leads 12,401 EDHREC decks (rank #192)
    • Pro: EDHREC tags 862 Wick decks as Rats, more than any other commander
    • Con: Three colours (blue, black, red) to pay for its Snail ability

    Price

    $0.30Scryfall, 18 November 2026

  4. Karumonix, the Rat King

    Karumonix, the Rat King

    The mono-black poison option

    • Pro: Leads 7,097 EDHREC decks (rank #417)
    • Pro: Gives every other Rat toxic 1 and digs for Rats when it enters
    • Con: Poison is a second win condition you have to build toward

    Price

    $0.91Scryfall, 18 November 2026

The Short Answer

Marrow-Gnawer is the best rat commander by the numbers. It leads 14,634 decks on EDHREC (18 November 2026), the most of any rat commander and rank #143 of all commanders. It is also the expensive one: $24.57 for the cheapest printing on Scryfall.

The budget pick is Vren, the Relentless: 13,063 decks for $0.71. Wick, the Whorled Mind (12,401 decks) costs $0.30.

There is no rat precon. None of the 208 Commander decks MTGJSON lists is led by a Rat, so a rat deck is built from singles.

  • $24.5714,634 decks
  • $0.7113,063 decks
  • $0.30Wick, the Whorled Mind

Rats are a black tribe that makes a lot of tokens, and two of its best-known cards say a deck can run any number of them. This page ranks every commander that leads a rat deck by how many people have actually built it on EDHREC, explains what the top seven do, and lists the cards most of their decks run. For how typal decks work in general, see our MTG tribal decks guide.

The Best Rat Commanders, Ranked

  • 1.Marrow-Gnawer

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    14,634 (#143)
    What it does
    Rats have fear; sacrifice a Rat to double your Rats

    $24.57

  • 2.Vren, the Relentless

    Colours
    Blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    13,063 (#178)
    What it does
    Exiles opposing creatures that die, makes Rats for each

    $0.71

  • 3.Wick, the Whorled Mind

    Colours
    Blue-black-red
    EDHREC decks
    12,401 (#192)
    What it does
    Rats grow a Snail; sacrifice it to burn and draw

    $0.30

  • 4.Karumonix, the Rat King

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    7,097 (#417)
    What it does
    Other Rats have toxic 1; finds Rats when it enters

    $0.91

  • 5.Rat King, Verminister

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    5,702 (#539)
    What it does
    Makes Rats; sacrifice three to return every copy of a creature

    $1.56

  • 6.Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    3,643 (#783)
    What it does
    Pumps Rats in combat; returns Rats from the graveyard

    $4.58

  • 7.Totentanz, Swarm Piper

    Colours
    Black-red
    EDHREC decks
    1,799 (#1,255)
    What it does
    Makes a Rat whenever your nontoken creatures die

    $0.32

  • 8.Nashi, Moon's Legacy

    Colours
    Black-green-blue
    EDHREC decks
    1,382 (#1,446)
    What it does
    Copies a legendary or Rat card from your graveyard on attack

    $0.26

  • 9.Lord Skitter, Sewer King

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    710 (#1,967)
    What it does
    A Rat each combat on your turn; Rats exile opposing graveyard cards

    $4.46

  • 10.Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    443 (#2,337)
    What it does
    Ninjutsu Rat that steals creatures from graveyards

    $9.43

  • 11.Patron of the Nezumi

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    179 (#3,002)
    What it does
    Rat offering; opponents lose life when their permanents hit the graveyard

    $0.46

  • 12.Rat King, Pale Piper

    Colours
    Black
    EDHREC decks
    120 (#3,315)
    What it does
    Makes a Rat when your nontoken creatures leave; sacrifice tokens to draw

    $0.32

How to read it. EDHREC decks is the number of decks EDHREC lists for that commander on 18 November 2026, with its rank among all commanders in brackets. Price is the cheapest English paper printing on Scryfall on 18 November 2026. Totentanz (a Human) and Patron of the Nezumi (a Spirit) aren't Rats themselves, but their decks are built around Rats.

The top three are close: Marrow-Gnawer, Vren and Wick are separated by 2,233 decks, and all three are in the top 200 commanders. After them the count drops by more than 40%, to 7,097 for Karumonix.


1. Marrow-Gnawer

Cost: {3}{B}{B}, 2/3 legendary Rat Rogue EDHREC: 14,634 decks, rank #143 (18 November 2026) Price: $24.57 for the borderless Bloomburrow Commander printing, $31.87 for the 2004 Champions of Kamigawa original (Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. All Rats have fear, so they can only be blocked by artifact or black creatures. Tap Marrow-Gnawer and sacrifice a Rat to create a 1/1 black Rat token for each Rat you control. Every activation roughly doubles your board, and the fear makes it hard for most decks to block.

Who it suits: players who want the classic mono-black rat deck: go wide, then attack. EDHREC tags 799 of its decks as Rats and 699 as Rat Colony.

Key cards in Marrow-Gnawer decks:

  • Piper of the Swarm ($1.82): in 12,056 of 14,634 decks. Rats have menace, it makes a Rat for {1}{B}, and it steals a creature for three Rats.
  • Pack Rat ($3.48): in 11,519. Its power and toughness equal the number of Rats you control, and it copies itself for {2}{B} and a discard.
  • Ogre Slumlord ($0.37): in 11,336. Makes a Rat whenever another nontoken creature dies and gives your Rats deathtouch.
  • Rat Colony ($5.33): in 11,033. Any number allowed in a deck, and each gets +1/+0 for every other Rat.
  • Thrumming Stone ($19.80): in 6,518. Gives your spells ripple 4, so casting one Rat Colony can cast more copies from the top of your library for free.

Cheapest way in: singles. No precon contains Marrow-Gnawer; the $24.57 borderless printing is the cheapest English copy Scryfall lists.


2. Vren, the Relentless

Cost: {2}{U}{B}, 3/4 legendary Rat Rogue with ward {2} EDHREC: 13,063 decks, rank #178 (18 November 2026) Price: $0.71 (Bloomburrow, Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. If a creature an opponent controls would die, it is exiled instead. At the beginning of each end step, not just yours, you create a 1/1 black Rat for every creature exiled from your opponents this turn, and each of those tokens gets +1/+1 for each other Rat you control. Removal and board wipes become Rat factories.

Who it suits: control players. Vren decks run removal and edicts alongside the Rats; EDHREC's top tags for it are Rats (670), Tokens (553) and Control (491).

Cards most Vren decks run:

  • Piper of the Swarm ($1.82): in 9,461 of 13,063 decks
  • Marrow-Gnawer ($24.57+): in 8,806
  • Lord Skitter, Sewer King ($4.46): in 8,340. A Rat at the beginning of combat on your turn, and every other Rat entering exiles up to one card from an opponent's graveyard.
  • Sheoldred's Edict ($1.51): in 7,601. Each opponent sacrifices a creature, which Vren exiles and turns into a Rat.
  • Accursed Marauder ($0.35): in 7,042. Each player sacrifices a nontoken creature when it enters.

Cheapest way in: singles. Vren was printed in Bloomburrow, but none of the four Bloomburrow Commander decks includes it.


3. Wick, the Whorled Mind

Cost: {3}{B}, 2/4 legendary Rat Warlock (colour identity blue-black-red) EDHREC: 12,401 decks, rank #192 (18 November 2026) Price: $0.30 (Bloomburrow, Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. Whenever Wick or another Rat enters under your control, you create a 1/1 Snail if you don't control one; otherwise you put a +1/+1 counter on your Snail. For {U}{B}{R}, sacrifice the Snail: Wick deals damage equal to the Snail's power to each opponent, then you draw that many cards. Every Rat token is a step toward the next hit.

Who it suits: players who like a token deck with reach. EDHREC tags 862 Wick decks as Rats, more than any other commander, ahead of Marrow-Gnawer (799).

Cards most Wick decks run:

  • Lord Skitter, Sewer King ($4.46): in 9,879 of 12,401 decks
  • Vren, the Relentless ($0.71): in 9,707
  • Song of Totentanz ($4.56): in 9,037. X Rats for {X}{R}, and your creatures gain haste. With Wick, X Rats is X counters on the Snail.
  • Piper of the Swarm ($1.82): in 8,925
  • Persistent Marshstalker ($0.38): in 8,049. Gets +1/+0 per other Rat, and with seven or more cards in your graveyard you can pay {2}{B} to return it attacking when you attack with Rats.

Cheapest way in: singles. At $0.30, Wick is the cheapest commander in the top five.


4. Karumonix, the Rat King

Cost: {1}{B}{B}, 3/3 legendary Phyrexian Rat with toxic 1 EDHREC: 7,097 decks, rank #417 (18 November 2026) Price: $0.91 (Phyrexia: All Will Be One, Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. Other Rats you control have toxic 1, so each one that deals combat damage to a player also gives a poison counter. A player with 10 poison counters loses. When Karumonix enters, look at the top five cards of your library and put any Rat cards among them into your hand.

Who it suits: players who want a second way to win. EDHREC's top tags are Infect (495) and Rats (477).

Cards most Karumonix decks run:

  • Piper of the Swarm ($1.82): in 5,701 of 7,097 decks
  • Blightbelly Rat ($0.29): in 5,494. Toxic 1, and it proliferates when it dies.
  • Ogre Slumlord ($0.37): in 5,274
  • Pack Rat ($3.48): in 5,155
  • Ichor Rats ($3.31): in 4,783. Infect, and each player gets a poison counter when it enters.

Cheapest way in: singles. Karumonix is also one of the most-played cards in other rat decks: 11,265 Marrow-Gnawer decks run it.


5. Rat King, Verminister

Cost: {1}{B}, 1/1 legendary Rat Avatar EDHREC: 5,702 decks, rank #539 (18 November 2026) Price: $1.56 (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. Disappear: at the beginning of your end step, if a permanent left the battlefield under your control this turn, create a 1/1 Rat and put a +1/+1 counter on Rat King. Tap it and sacrifice three Rats to return a creature card and every other card with the same name from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped. With Rat Colony or Relentless Rats, one activation brings back every copy in the graveyard.

Who it suits: players who want the "any number of copies" deck. Rat Colony is in 4,527 of its 5,702 decks.

Cards most Rat King decks run:

  • Marrow-Gnawer ($24.57+): in 4,738 of 5,702 decks
  • Rat Colony ($5.33): in 4,527
  • Piper of the Swarm ($1.82): in 4,281
  • Thrumming Stone ($19.80): in 4,174
  • Bloodline Bidding ($2.60): in 2,895. Returns every creature card of the chosen type from your graveyard.

Cheapest way in: singles. Rat King, Verminister is from the main TMNT set, not from the TMNT Commander deck.


6. Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm

Cost: {3}{B}, 3/4 legendary Rat Warlock EDHREC: 3,643 decks, rank #783 (18 November 2026) Price: $4.58 for the borderless Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Source Material printing (March 2026); the Jumpstart 2022 original is $35.71 (Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. Whenever Ashcoat attacks or blocks, your other Rats get +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the number of Rats you control. At the beginning of your end step you may mill four cards, and if you do, return up to two Rat creature cards from your graveyard to your hand.

Who it suits: aggressive players. Its top cards are the same as Marrow-Gnawer's: Marrow-Gnawer itself (in 3,147 of 3,643 decks), Piper of the Swarm (2,861), Karumonix (2,741), Pack Rat (2,686) and Rat Colony (2,592).

Cheapest way in: buy the 2026 reprint. It costs about an eighth of the Jumpstart 2022 copy.


7. Totentanz, Swarm Piper

Cost: {1}{B}{R}, 2/3 legendary Human Warlock Bard EDHREC: 1,799 decks, rank #1,255 (18 November 2026) Price: $0.32 (Wilds of Eldraine, Scryfall, 18 November 2026)

What it does. Whenever Totentanz or another nontoken creature you control dies, create a 1/1 Rat that can't block. For {1}{B}, an attacking Rat gains deathtouch. It isn't a Rat, but it makes them, and red adds Song of Totentanz and damage payoffs.

Who it suits: sacrifice (aristocrats) players. Its top tags are Aristocrats (120), Tokens (120) and Rats (116).

Cards most Totentanz decks run: Piper of the Swarm (in 1,440 of 1,799 decks), Ogre Slumlord (1,432), Song of Totentanz (1,425), Lord Skitter, Sewer King (1,415) and Lord Skitter's Butcher (1,313).


The Other Five, Briefly

  • Nashi, Moon's Legacy (1,382 decks, $0.26): black-green-blue. Whenever it attacks, exile up to one legendary or Rat card from your graveyard and copy it; you may cast the copy.
  • Lord Skitter, Sewer King (710 decks, $4.46): makes a Rat that can't block at the beginning of combat on your turn. It is played far more in other rat decks (9,879 Wick decks) than as a commander.
  • Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni (443 decks, from $9.43): a Rat Ninja with ninjutsu that puts a creature from the damaged player's graveyard onto the battlefield under your control.
  • Patron of the Nezumi (179 decks, $0.46): a 7-mana Spirit you can cast at instant speed by sacrificing a Rat and paying the difference in mana (rat offering). Opponents lose 1 life whenever one of their permanents goes to the graveyard.
  • Rat King, Pale Piper (120 decks, $0.32): makes a Rat whenever it or another nontoken creature you control leaves the battlefield, and sacrifices tokens to draw.

Rats that don't lead rat decks

Four Rat commanders have more decks than some of the list above, but their decks aren't built around Rats, so we left them out of the ranking:

  • Greasefang, Okiba Boss (6,691 decks): a Vehicles deck. EDHREC tags 1,311 of its decks as Vehicles and 42 as Rats.
  • Splinter, Radical Rat (6,174 decks): a Ninjas deck (365 tagged Ninjas, 9 Rats).
  • Nashi, Searcher in the Dark (1,562 decks): an enchantments and legends deck.
  • Freya Crescent (757 decks): an Equipment deck.

Best Budget Rat Commander

Vren, the Relentless at $0.71. It has 13,063 EDHREC decks, 89% as many as Marrow-Gnawer, which costs 35 times as much. If you want to stay in mono-black, Karumonix is $0.91; if you want the lowest price in the top five, Wick is $0.30.

Most of the cards rat decks share are cheap too. Scryfall prices on 18 November 2026:

CardPriceWhat it adds
Piper of the Swarm$1.82Menace for Rats, a Rat each turn
Ogre Slumlord$0.37Rats when creatures die, deathtouch
Lord Skitter's Butcher$0.30A Rat, a card, or menace for your team
Persistent Marshstalker$0.38A Rat that comes back attacking
Tangled Colony$0.76Rats equal to the damage it took
Typhoid Rats$0.32A one-mana deathtouch blocker
Crypt Rats$0.59A board wipe you control with black mana

Those seven add up to $4.54. The pricier rat-deck staples are Marrow-Gnawer ($24.57+), Thrumming Stone ($19.80) and Jet Medallion ($15.69, in 9,579 Marrow-Gnawer decks), and none of them is required.

Is There a Rat Precon?

No. We checked all 208 Commander decks in MTGJSON's deck list, up to the Star Trek decks of November 2026, and none has a Rat as its commander. The closest options:

  • Turtle Power!, the TMNT Commander deck, includes Rat King, Pale Piper (rank #12 above) and Splinter, the Mentor, but it is a five-colour turtles deck with two Rats in it. It sold for $48.49 on 17 November 2026 (TCGplayer market).
  • The Jumpstart 2022 Rats pack contains Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm and seven other Rats, but it is a 20-card Jumpstart pack, not a Commander deck.
  • Bloomburrow printed Vren, Wick and many cheap Rats, but its four Bloomburrow Commander decks are led by other animals.

For every Commander precon since 2023 and what it sells for, see our Commander precon price table.

What Makes a Good Rat Deck

  • Black mana. Scryfall lists 111 paper cards with the Rat type on 18 November 2026, and 102 of them are black. Blue has 12, most from Bloomburrow.
  • Token makers. Piper of the Swarm, Ogre Slumlord, Lord Skitter and Song of Totentanz turn one Rat into many, and every commander above rewards a wide board.
  • The "any number" Rats. Rat Colony and Relentless Rats both let a deck run as many copies as you like, which Thrumming Stone and Rat King, Verminister both exploit.
  • A way through blockers. Menace from Piper, fear from Marrow-Gnawer and deathtouch from Ogre Slumlord turn a board of 1/1s into damage.
  • Sacrifice outlets. Several of the commanders pay you for Rats leaving play or dying, so cards like Village Rites (in 7,017 Marrow-Gnawer decks) do double duty.

Are any rat commanders Game Changers?

No. We checked the 12 commanders in the ranking and the cards listed on this page against the Game Changers list and found none of them on it. Many rat decks add Game Changers anyway, which raises their bracket: Demonic Tutor is in 4,696 Marrow-Gnawer decks (32%) and Rhystic Study in 3,104 Vren decks (24%) on EDHREC.

Conclusion: Marrow-Gnawer to Go Big, Vren to Start Cheap

Marrow-Gnawer is the rat commander most people build, with 14,634 EDHREC decks, and it is the purest rat deck: fear for every Rat and a button that doubles your board. It also costs $24.57 or more, with no precon to lower the price.

Vren, the Relentless is nearly as popular at $0.71, and Wick, the Whorled Mind is $0.30. Start with either, add Piper of the Swarm, Ogre Slumlord and Pack Rat, and pick up Marrow-Gnawer for the 99 later. For other tribes, see our MTG tribal decks guide.


Citations & Resources


Frequently Asked Questions