Infect MTG: Toxic, Poison Counters and How They Work (2026)

Infect in MTG turns damage into poison and -1/-1 counters; toxic adds poison on top of normal damage. Ten poison counters loses the game, even in Commander.

Shon Atsil11 min readMagic
Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon fanned with Glistener Elf, Blighted Agent, Venerated Rotpriest and Ixhel, Scion of Atraxa on a dark background

Quick verdict

A player with ten or more poison counters loses the game, whatever their life total. Infect makes a source deal its damage to players as poison counters and to creatures as -1/-1 counters, for any damage, not only combat. Toxic N is the newer version: combat damage to a player is dealt normally and the player also gets N poison counters. Poisonous is an older trigger on only two cards. Proliferate adds one more poison counter to every poisoned player you choose, and Commander keeps the limit at ten.

Infect in MTG makes a source deal damage to players as poison counters and to creatures as -1/-1 counters, and a player with ten or more poison counters loses the game. Toxic is the newer poison keyword: a creature with toxic N deals combat damage to a player as normal, and that player also gets N poison counters. Both race toward the same ten counters, which is why a poison deck can win while the opponent is still on 20, or 40, life.

Poison counters are older than either keyword. They first appeared on Pit Scorpion and Serpent Generator in Legends (1994). Infect arrived with Scars of Mirrodin in October 2010, and toxic with Phyrexia: All Will Be One in February 2023.

Poison Counters: the Rule That Ends the Game

Rule 104.3d of the Comprehensive Rules is short:

If a player has ten or more poison counters, that player loses the game the next time a player would receive priority.

That makes it a state-based action, the same kind of check that ends the game at 0 life. Nobody can respond to it. A player is "poisoned" as soon as they have one poison counter.

What poison counters don't do is just as important:

  • They don't cost life. Your life total and your poison count are separate. A player on 40 life with ten poison counters has lost.
  • They don't go away. There is no "end of turn" for poison counters. Only a card that explicitly removes them takes them off.
  • They are counters. Anything that cares about counters on a player, especially proliferate, works on them. Our guide to every MTG counter covers the rest.

Ten is the number in every common format. The one exception is Two-Headed Giant, where the team shares one poison count and loses at fifteen. Archenemy's Commander option shares the opposing team's life total but not poison, so each player there still loses at ten.

Infect Rules in MTG

Glistener Elf's reminder text sums it up:

Infect (This creature deals damage to creatures in the form of -1/-1 counters and to players in the form of poison counters.)

Rule 702.90 and the card rulings fill in the details:

  1. Damage to a player becomes poison counters. The player doesn't lose life. They get poison counters equal to the damage dealt.
  2. Damage to a creature becomes -1/-1 counters. The damage isn't marked; the creature gets that many -1/-1 counters instead. They stay at the end of the turn and after regeneration.
  3. Planeswalkers and battles are unchanged. Infect damage removes loyalty counters from a planeswalker and defense counters from a battle as normal.
  4. It's any damage. Infect isn't limited to combat. If a source with infect deals damage through a fight or an ability, the same rules apply.
  5. It's still damage. Lifelink still gains you life. Damage prevention still works, and prevented infect damage gives no counters. "Whenever this deals damage" triggers still trigger.
  6. One instance is enough. Multiple instances of infect on the same object are redundant.

The -1/-1 counter part is why infect creatures are hard to block profitably. A 2/2 that blocks a 1/1 with infect doesn't heal at end of turn; it is permanently a 1/1.

Pump spells count double. With infect, every point of power is a poison counter. That is the whole idea behind the classic infect deck: a one-mana 1/1 plus two pump spells is ten poison counters on turn two or three.

Toxic Rules in MTG

Bloated Contaminator shows the reminder text:

Toxic 1 (Players dealt combat damage by this creature also get a poison counter.)

Rule 702.164 makes toxic a static ability with a number after it:

  1. Combat damage to a player is dealt normally. The player loses life as usual and gets poison counters equal to the creature's total toxic value.
  2. The number is fixed. A creature with toxic 1 gives one poison counter whether it deals 1 damage or 10. Pump spells add damage, not poison.
  3. Only combat damage to players. Toxic does nothing when the creature hits a creature or planeswalker, or deals noncombat damage.
  4. Toxic stacks. A creature's "total toxic value" is the sum of all its toxic abilities. Toxic 2 plus toxic 1 means three poison counters.
  5. Damage doublers don't change it. If an effect doubles the damage, the number of poison counters stays the same. Effects that change the number of counters, such as Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider, do apply.

Because toxic doesn't replace damage, a toxic deck threatens two clocks at once: the opponent's life total and their poison count. That is the design choice behind the mechanic.

Toxic vs Infect: What's the Difference?

Infect replaces damage with counters; toxic adds poison counters on top of normal damage. Infect gives poison equal to the damage dealt, so pumping an infect creature speeds up the poison clock. Toxic gives a set number of poison counters, so pumping a toxic creature only speeds up the life clock.

  • Rule

    Infect
    702.90 (static ability)
    Toxic N
    702.164 (static ability)
  • Damage to a player

    Infect
    Poison counters instead of life loss
    Toxic N
    Normal life loss plus N poison counters
  • How many poison counters

    Infect
    Equal to the damage dealt
    Toxic N
    Equal to total toxic value, however much damage
  • Which damage

    Infect
    Any damage, combat or noncombat
    Toxic N
    Combat damage to a player only
  • Damage to a creature

    Infect
    -1/-1 counters instead of damage
    Toxic N
    Normal damage, no effect
  • Planeswalkers and battles

    Infect
    Normal
    Toxic N
    Normal
  • Pump spells

    Infect
    +3 power = 3 more poison
    Toxic N
    +3 power = 3 more damage, same poison
  • Multiple instances

    Infect
    Redundant
    Toxic N
    Add together
  • Lifelink

    Infect
    Works
    Toxic N
    Works
  • Introduced

    Infect
    Scars of Mirrodin, October 2010
    Toxic N
    Phyrexia: All Will Be One, February 2023
  • Cards with the keyword (Scryfall)

    Infect
    46
    Toxic N
    43

A worked example makes it concrete. Your opponent is on 20 life with no poison counters, and three creatures connect:

  • A 1/1 with infect, pumped by Mutagenic Growth (+2/+2): 3 poison counters, no life loss.
  • Bloated Contaminator, a 4/4 with toxic 1: 4 damage and 1 poison counter. Its trigger then proliferates, so they get a second poison counter.
  • Necrogen Rotpriest, a 1/5 with toxic 2: 1 damage and 2 poison counters, plus 1 more from its own ability.

Can a creature have both? Yes, and the rules simply add them. If an infect creature gains toxic (from Skrelv, Defector Mite, for example), combat damage to a player gives poison equal to the damage from infect, plus the toxic value on top.

Which one is stronger depends on the format. Infect is the faster kill because pump spells convert directly into poison, but its creatures are weak as blockers and do nothing to the life total. Toxic is slower and fairer, and it plays like a normal aggressive deck that also builds a second win condition. Scryfall lists no new card with the infect keyword since New Phyrexia in 2011, apart from one Unfinity sticker-sheet card. When Phyrexia returned in 2023, the poison keyword was toxic.

Poisonous and Other Ways to Give Poison

Poisonous N (rule 702.70) is the older keyword: a triggered ability that reads "Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, that player gets N poison counters." Multiple instances trigger separately. It came from Future Sight in 2007 and is on only two cards: Virulent Sliver, which gives all Slivers poisonous 1, and Snake Cult Initiation, an Aura that gives poisonous 3.

The first poison cards had no keyword at all. Pit Scorpion (Legends, 1994) says "Whenever this creature deals damage to a player, that player gets a poison counter," and Swamp Mosquito (Alliances, 1996) gives one whenever it attacks and isn't blocked.

Many cards give poison directly, most of them from Phyrexia: All Will Be One on (Fynn first appeared in Kaldheim, 2021):

  • Prologue to Phyresis ({1}{U}): each opponent gets a poison counter, draw a card.
  • Vraska's Fall ({2}{B}): each opponent sacrifices a creature or planeswalker and gets a poison counter.
  • Infectious Inquiry ({2}{B}): draw two, lose 2 life, each opponent gets a poison counter.
  • Infectious Bite ({1}{G}): your creature damages one of theirs, each opponent gets a poison counter.
  • Fynn, the Fangbearer ({1}{G}): whenever a creature you control with deathtouch deals combat damage to a player, that player gets two poison counters.
  • Vraska, Betrayal's Sting: her -9 sets a player with fewer than nine poison counters to exactly nine.

Corrupted: Rewards for Three Poison Counters

Corrupted is the label on Phyrexia: All Will Be One cards whose ability switches on once an opponent has three or more poison counters. It has no rules of its own; each card says what it does.

  • Glistening Sphere taps for three mana of one colour instead of one.
  • Skrelv's Hive gives your toxic creatures lifelink.
  • Ixhel, Scion of Atraxa exiles the top card of each corrupted opponent's library at your end step, and you may play those cards.

Three poison counters is easy to reach with a couple of toxic hits or one proliferate turn, so corrupted turns a slow poison start into card or mana advantage while you finish the job.

Proliferate and Poison

Proliferate gives every chosen player or permanent another counter of each kind it already has. For a poison deck, every proliferate is one more poison counter on every poisoned opponent you choose, and you can skip your own creatures and players you don't want to help.

It also doesn't target, so a player can't hide behind hexproof. That is why the best proliferate cards are in every poison deck:

  • Atraxa, Praetors' Voice proliferates at every end step.
  • Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominus makes you proliferate twice whenever you would proliferate once.
  • Evolution Sage, Flux Channeler and Thrummingbird proliferate off lands, noncreature spells and combat damage.
  • Karn's Bastion and Contagion Engine proliferate from a land and an artifact; Contagion Engine does it twice per activation.
  • Inexorable Tide proliferates whenever you cast a spell.

In Two-Headed Giant, if you choose both players on a poisoned team, only one of them gets the extra counter, because the team shares its poison.

Counter doublers: Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider doubles counters you put on permanents and players, and Wizards' toxic rulings (on Bloated Contaminator) confirm it applies to toxic poison counters. Doubling Season does not, because it only doubles counters on permanents you control, and a player is not a permanent.

Infect in Modern and Pauper

Infect's competitive home was Modern, built around one-drops and land creatures with infect:

  • Glistener Elf ({G}) and Blighted Agent ({1}{U}, can't be blocked), both from New Phyrexia (2011).
  • Inkmoth Nexus, a land that becomes a 1/1 flier with infect.
  • Cheap pump and protection spells such as Mutagenic Growth, Groundswell, Might of Old Krosa, Vines of Vastwood and Become Immense.

Phyrexian mana mattered to the deck. Gitaxian Probe, a free look at the opponent's hand that also drew a card, was a staple of infect and other aggressive Modern decks until it was banned in Modern in January 2017. It is also banned in Legacy and Pauper today.

Glistener Elf and Blighted Agent are commons, so both are legal in Pauper as well. On 19 November 2026 Scryfall lists the cheapest non-foil copy of Inkmoth Nexus (the Edge of Eternities: Stellar Sights printing) at $11.87.

Best Infect and Toxic Commanders

Poison is a real way to win in Commander: each opponent starts on 40 life but still loses at ten poison counters. EDHREC's Infect theme (which also counts toxic and other poison decks) lists these among its top commanders by deck count on 19 November 2026 (it also ranks Brimaz, Blight of Oreskos, Kilo, Apogee Mind and a few others between Skithiryx and Skrelv):

  • Atraxa, Praetors' Voice

    Colours
    WUBG
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    3,427
    What it does
    Proliferates every end step

    $24.66

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

  • Fynn, the Fangbearer

    Colours
    G
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    1,502
    What it does
    Deathtouch creatures give two poison

    $0.19

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

  • Ixhel, Scion of Atraxa

    Colours
    WBG
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    1,044
    What it does
    Flying toxic 2; corrupted card theft

    $2.42

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

  • Vishgraz, the Doomhive

    Colours
    WBG
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    768
    What it does
    Makes three toxic Mites; grows with poison

    $1.24

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

  • Karumonix, the Rat King

    Colours
    B
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    496
    What it does
    Gives your Rats toxic 1

    $0.91

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

  • Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon

    Colours
    B
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    441
    What it does
    4/4 flier with infect, haste and regeneration

    $10.68

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

  • Skrelv, Defector Mite

    Colours
    W
    Decks on EDHREC (Infect theme)
    257
    What it does
    Gives a creature toxic 1 and evasion

    $3.33

    Cheapest copy, 19 Nov 2026

Prices are the cheapest non-foil printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026: Atraxa from Multiverse Legends, Fynn from The List, Skithiryx from Marvel Universe, Ixhel and Vishgraz from Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander, Karumonix and Skrelv from Phyrexia: All Will Be One.

Atraxa, Praetors' Voice is the default for a reason: four colours give it every proliferate card, and a proliferate trigger every turn means each poison counter you land keeps growing. Ixhel and Vishgraz both come from Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander, and both want to spread toxic across a wide board. Fynn is the budget pick: any deathtouch creature becomes a two-poison threat, and mono-green has plenty of them. Skithiryx is the classic mono-black infect commander; with {B} for haste it hits for four poison in the air the turn it lands, and it can regenerate.

Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider isn't a typical poison commander, but in the 99 it doubles every poison counter you give and halves the counters your opponents put on things.

Best Infect and Toxic Cards

Inkmoth Nexus. A land that attacks as a 1/1 flier with infect, so it survives sorcery-speed removal.

Blighted Agent. Unblockable infect for two mana, and the best target for pump spells.

Phyrexian Crusader. First strike, protection from red and white, and infect: very hard for two colours to deal with.

Triumph of the Hordes. Your whole team gets +1/+1, trample and infect until end of turn. In Commander it turns a board of tokens into a one-turn kill.

Tainted Strike and Grafted Exoskeleton. Give infect to a creature that doesn't have it.

Phyresis Outbreak. Each opponent gets a poison counter, then their creatures get -1/-1 for each poison counter they have. A one-sided board wipe in a poison deck.

Venerated Rotpriest. A one-drop with toxic 1 that gives a poison counter whenever one of your creatures becomes the target of a spell, including your own pump spells.

Bloated Contaminator. A 4/4 trampler for three with toxic 1 that proliferates whenever it connects.

Necrogen Rotpriest. Every toxic creature you control gives one extra poison counter.

Vraska, Betrayal's Sting. Draws and proliferates every turn with her 0, and her ultimate puts a player to nine.

Glistening Sphere. Mana rock and proliferate in one, and it taps for three once an opponent is corrupted.

Norn's Decree. Punishes opponents who attack you with a poison counter and draws cards for anyone attacking a poisoned player, which pushes the table to attack each other.

Common Mistakes

"Toxic gives poison equal to the damage." It doesn't. It gives exactly the toxic number, however big the creature is.

"Infect only works in combat." It works on any damage the source deals.

"Poison counters fall off at the end of the turn." They stay for the rest of the game.

"Commander games need 21 poison counters." No. The 21 is commander damage; poison is ten.

"Infect creatures can't hurt planeswalkers." They can. Damage to planeswalkers removes loyalty as normal.

"Life gain stops poison." Life and poison are separate. Gaining life does nothing to your poison count.

Where Poison Fits

A poison deck is built from pieces covered in other guides: proliferate for scaling, deathtouch for Fynn, and lifelink, which still works with infect and toxic. For every other keyword on these cards, see our complete MTG keywords glossary.


Citations & Resources


Frequently Asked Questions