Commander Precon vs Build From Scratch: Real Costs (2026)

Precon or build from scratch? 2025-26 precons cost $27 to $85; EDHREC's average Ur-Dragon deck is about $1,180 in singles. Cost, power and which to pick.

Shon Atsil9 min readMagic
Five commanders from recent precons fanned on a dark background: Y'shtola, Night's Blessed in the centre, with Quintorius, History Chaser, Sai, Master Thopterist, Commander Spock and Saheeli, Radiant Creator

Our top 4 picks

Ranked. Pick one to read why, and what it costs.

  1. Top pick
    1

    Foundations Commander Deck: Keen Engineering

    The best first deck to upgrade: the precon behind this guide's $43 upgrade plan

    $30.03TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  2. 2

    Reality Fracture Commander Deck: Multiverse Reforged

    The best precon to play as it comes

    $45.63TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  3. 3

    Secrets of Strixhaven Commander Deck: Prismari Artistry

    About twice its price in cards, and Draftsim's pick for competitive potential among the five Strixhaven decks

    $44.14TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  4. 4

    Aetherdrift Commander Deck: Living Energy

    The cheapest of the 84 decks in our precon tracker on 17 November 2026

    $27.26TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

Commander decks

  1. Foundations Commander Deck: Keen EngineeringTop pick

    Foundations Commander Deck: Keen Engineering

    The best first deck to upgrade: the precon behind this guide's $43 upgrade plan

    • Pro: $30.03 for about $59 of cards (card value from our precon tracker, 17 Nov 2026)
    • Pro: Mono-blue artifacts led by Sai, Master Thopterist, made for new players
    • Pro: 17 upgrades for $43.46 bring it close to EDHREC's average Sai deck
    • Con: One colour and simple cards, by design: it is weaker than a regular precon as it comes

    Price

    $30.03TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  2. Reality Fracture Commander Deck: Multiverse Reforged

    Reality Fracture Commander Deck: Multiverse Reforged

    The best precon to play as it comes

    • Pro: $45.63 for about $88 of cards (17 Nov 2026)
    • Pro: Draftsim: "certainly one of the best precons of the year"
    • Pro: Ninth of 93 on Playgroup.gg's precon win-rate list (28.52% over 959 games, 19 Nov 2026)
    • Con: Four colours (white, blue, black and red) to manage

    Price

    $45.63TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  3. Secrets of Strixhaven Commander Deck: Prismari Artistry

    Secrets of Strixhaven Commander Deck: Prismari Artistry

    About twice its price in cards, and Draftsim's pick for competitive potential among the five Strixhaven decks

    • Pro: $44.14 for about $90 of cards (17 Nov 2026)
    • Pro: Faerie Mastermind ($12.48) and Goldspan Dragon ($11.95) inside
    • Pro: Draftsim picks it as the Strixhaven deck with the highest competitive potential
    • Con: A blue-red spells deck: more decisions each turn than a creature deck

    Price

    $44.14TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  4. Aetherdrift Commander Deck: Living Energy

    Aetherdrift Commander Deck: Living Energy

    The cheapest of the 84 decks in our precon tracker on 17 November 2026

    • Pro: $27.26 for about $57 of cards (17 Nov 2026)
    • Pro: Saheeli, Radiant Creator in blue, red and green
    • Pro: Panharmonicon, Academy Ruins and Lightning Greaves inside
    • Con: Released February 2025, with less card value than the newer picks

    Price

    $27.26TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

The Short Answer

Buy a Commander precon if it's your first deck, you want to play this week, or you like one of the precon commanders. On 17 November 2026, every precon from 2025 and 2026 sold for $27 to $85 on TCGplayer, ready to play at about Bracket 2.

Build from scratch if you want a commander that has no precon, or a deck stronger than a precon. It costs more than most people expect: EDHREC's average deck for The Ur-Dragon comes to about $1,180 in singles.

For most players, the best value is in between: buy a precon, then upgrade it. Keen Engineering ($29.90) plus 17 cheap upgrades (about $43) gets close to EDHREC's average Sai deck, which costs about $127 built from scratch.

Commander Precon vs Build: The Comparison Table

  • Cost (Nov 2026)

    Precon
    $27 to $85 for 2025-26 decks
    Precon + upgrades
    Deck price plus $25 to $50
    Built from scratch
    About $127 (Sai) to $1,180 (The Ur-Dragon) for EDHREC's average deck
  • Power

    Precon
    About Bracket 2
    Precon + upgrades
    Bracket 2 or 3
    Built from scratch
    Any bracket you build for
  • Time to first game

    Precon
    Open the box
    Precon + upgrades
    Play now, upgrade as cards arrive
    Built from scratch
    Choose 99 cards, then order singles
  • What you learn

    Precon
    How Commander plays
    Precon + upgrades
    Which cards are weak, and why
    Built from scratch
    Mana bases, curves, card choices
  • Commander choice

    Precon
    The few in print
    Precon + upgrades
    The few in print
    Built from scratch
    Any legal commander
  • Resale

    Precon
    Sealed out-of-print decks can rise; opened, about a quarter is bulk
    Precon + upgrades
    Same, plus the upgrades
    Built from scratch
    Value sits in a few staples; reprints can cut it

Precon prices are TCGplayer market prices on 17 November 2026 from our Commander precon tracker. Build costs add up each card of EDHREC's average deck in its cheapest printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026; basic lands count as free.

What a Commander Precon Costs

Wizards' regular Commander decks list at $49.99 since Lorwyn Eclipsed (January 2026), up from $44.99. Universes Beyond decks cost more: $69.99 for Final Fantasy, $74.99 for Marvel Super Heroes and Star Trek. The Foundations Commander decks, made for new players, are $29.99.

Store prices drift well below those numbers. The 35 precons released in 2025 and 2026 sold for $27.06 to $84.57 on TCGplayer on 17 November 2026, with a median of $45.60. The four Star Trek decks, released on 13 November at $74.99, already sold for $39 to $71.

These are the ten newest decks, with this week's prices:

TCGplayer market prices, updated November 17, 2026. Price is the sealed deck. Cards worth adds up the market price of all 100 cards inside, foils as foils. Value is cards worth divided by price. Deck names, buttons and top cards link to TCGplayer; those are affiliate links.

For the full list of 84 decks and our picks, see every Commander precon priced. If you're still deciding which 2025 deck to start with, our 2025 precons ranked covers each one.

Four precons worth starting from

If you've decided on a precon, these four give the most for the money right now. Prices are TCGplayer market prices through tcgcsv.com on 19 November 2026; card values are from our tracker on 17 November.

DeckCommanderColoursPriceCards inside
Living Energy (Aetherdrift)Saheeli, Radiant CreatorBlue, red, green$27.26About $57
Keen Engineering (Foundations)Sai, Master ThopteristBlue$30.03About $59
Prismari Artistry (Secrets of Strixhaven)Rootha, Mastering the MomentBlue, red$44.14About $90
Multiverse Reforged (Reality Fracture)Jace, Multiverse ArchitectWhite, blue, black, red$45.63About $88

Keen Engineering is the one to buy if you plan to follow the upgrade below. Multiverse Reforged is the strongest to play as it comes: Draftsim called it "certainly one of the best precons of the year," and on 19 November 2026 it was ninth of 93 on Playgroup.gg's win-rate list for unmodified precons (28.52% over 959 games). Prismari Artistry holds about twice its price in cards, and Draftsim's pick for the Strixhaven deck with the highest competitive potential. Living Energy was the cheapest of the 84 decks in our tracker.

What Building a Commander Deck From Scratch Costs

To price a scratch build, we took EDHREC's "average deck" for three commanders, the most common 100 cards across every deck people have logged, and priced every card in its cheapest paper printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026.

CommanderDecks on EDHRECAverage deck from singlesSame commander's precon
Sai, Master Thopterist5,008About $127Keen Engineering, $29.90
Y'shtola, Night's Blessed60,005About $585Scions & Spellcraft, $58.89
The Ur-Dragon (budget list)51,840About $140None in print
The Ur-Dragon (average list)51,840About $1,180None in print

Three things stand out.

A precon is far cheaper than building the same commander. Y'shtola, Night's Blessed had more decks than any other commander on EDHREC's main top-commanders list when we checked on 19 November 2026. Her precon, Scions & Spellcraft from the Final Fantasy set, sold for $58.89, while the average Y'shtola deck costs about ten times that.

A few cards carry the price. In the average Ur-Dragon deck, the ten priciest cards make up 47% of the total: Ancient Copper Dragon ($117.48), Rhystic Study ($62.28), Demonic Tutor ($58.94), Smothering Tithe ($52.22), Old Gnawbone ($51.06), Cavern of Souls ($48.46) and four more. Meanwhile 23 of its cards cost under $1.

Cheap builds exist. EDHREC's budget Ur-Dragon list costs about $140, and the commander itself ($33.17 in its cheapest printing) is almost a quarter of that.

Cheapest printings also take work: you'll order from several sellers, and shipping adds up. Our deckbuilding guide covers the 100-card structure if you go this way.

Power Level and Commander Brackets

Wizards' Commander brackets run from 1 (Exhibition) to 5 (cEDH). The Game Changers list does much of the sorting: no Game Changers keeps a deck in Brackets 1 or 2, up to three is Bracket 3, four or more is Bracket 4 or 5.

  • Precons: most unmodified decks play at about Bracket 2, and some newer ones play like Bracket 3.
  • Built decks: wherever you take them. EDHREC's average Ur-Dragon deck has five Game Changers (Rhystic Study, Smothering Tithe, Cyclonic Rift, Teferi's Protection and Demonic Tutor), so it's Bracket 4 at least. The average Y'shtola deck has four. The budget Ur-Dragon list and the average Sai deck have none.

Of the Ur-Dragon decks on EDHREC with a bracket set, about 44% are Bracket 3, 31% Bracket 4 and 22% Bracket 2. So "built from scratch" usually means stronger than a precon, and a precon player at a Bracket 3 or 4 table will struggle.

The Middle Road: Precon Plus a $50 Upgrade

Buying the precon and upgrading it gets you the commander, a working mana base and dozens of on-theme cards for less than the singles cost. Keen Engineering shows how it works. It sold for $29.90 on 17 November 2026, and its 100 cards were worth about $59.

Sai, Master Thopterist makes a 1/1 flying Thopter whenever you cast an artifact spell, and {1}{U}, sacrifice two artifacts draws a card. The upgrades below are popular cards in Sai decks on EDHREC (each in 22% to 60% of them) that the precon doesn't include. Prices are each card's cheapest printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026.

AddWhyPrice
Efficient ConstructionA second Sai: a Thopter for each artifact spell$0.45
Stridehangar AutomatonAn extra Thopter whenever you make artifact tokens; Thopters get +1/+1$5.40
SkullclampEquip a 1/1 Thopter, it dies, you draw two$3.27
Mystic ForgeCast artifacts from the top of your library$3.43
Emry, Lurker of the LochCheap with artifacts out; recasts artifacts from your graveyard$0.90
Sharding SphinxMore Thopters from combat damage$0.29
Tezzeret, Artifice MasterA Thopter or two cards every turn$4.71
Mechanized ProductionCopies an artifact every upkeep; eight Thopters wins$2.81
Whir of InventionTutors an artifact onto the battlefield$5.68
FabricateTutors an artifact to your hand$6.46
Cloud KeyYour artifact spells cost {1} less$2.28
Idol of OblivionDraws a card on any turn you make a token$1.97
PongifyOne-mana creature removal$0.67
Rapid HybridizationOne-mana creature removal$0.31
Seat of the SynodArtifact land$0.99
Academy RuinsPuts an artifact back on top of your library$1.80
Reliquary TowerNo maximum hand size$2.04
Total17 cards$43.46

To make room, take out three Islands for the three lands, and 14 precon cards that few Sai decks on EDHREC keep (8% to 23% of them): Fall from Favor; Spire Golem; Cultivator's Caravan; Mazemind Tome; Skysovereign, Consul Flagship; Memory Guardian; Mind's Eye; Pull from Tomorrow; Darksteel Juggernaut; Broodstar; Psychosis Crawler; Steel Hellkite; Tamiyo's Logbook; and Myr Battlesphere. Keep the removal (Duplicant, Nevinyrral's Disk, Meteor Golem), even though fewer Sai lists play it.

That's about $73 in total, against about $127 for EDHREC's average Sai deck built from singles. None of the 17 is a Game Changer, so the deck stays Bracket 2 or 3. If you can stretch past $50, Urza, Lord High Artificer ($16.81) is the most-played expensive card in Sai decks.

What a First Commander Setup Costs

The deck isn't the only purchase. A 100-card deck needs 100 sleeves, and most players want a deck box that holds the whole thing sleeved. Here is the full bill for the Keen Engineering route, at TCGplayer market prices on 19 November 2026:

ItemPrice
Keen Engineering precon$30.03
Dragon Shield Matte sleeves, black, 100-pack$10.87
Gamegenic Bastion 100+ XL deck box, black$14.76
Ready to play$55.66
The 17 upgrades above (cheapest printings, Scryfall)$43.46
Upgraded$99.12

That's still less than EDHREC's average Sai deck from singles (about $127), and that figure doesn't include sleeves or a box. One 100-pack of sleeves covers the deck exactly, so buy a second pack if you want spares. For other brands, see our sleeve comparison and deck box guide.

Resale Value

Precons: on 17 November 2026, the cards in 69 of 84 precons since 2023 were worth more than the sealed deck, with a median of about 1.4 times the price. But about a quarter of that is bulk under $1, and selling costs fees and shipping. Sealed decks can climb once they're out of print: Eldrazi Unbound (2023) sold for about $411.

Built decks: the value is concentrated in staples, which are easy to sell or move to your next deck. The risk is reprints: a staple reprinted in a new precon or Secret Lair can drop fast.

Common Mistakes

With a precon:

  • Upgrading before you've played it. A few games show you which cards never do anything. Those are the ones to cut.
  • Buying Game Changers first. Rhystic Study and Smothering Tithe each cost more than the whole Keen Engineering upgrade, and each one moves the deck toward Bracket 3. Cheap synergy cards like Efficient Construction ($0.45) do more for a precon per dollar.
  • Cutting lands for spells. The three new lands above replace three Islands one for one, so the land count stays the same.

With a scratch build:

  • Buying the expensive staples first. In the average Ur-Dragon deck, the ten priciest cards are 47% of the cost. Build the cheap version, play it, then add staples the deck actually needs.
  • Ordering every card in its cheapest printing from a different seller. The singles total looks low, but shipping from many sellers adds up. Group orders where you can.
  • Building above your table's bracket. A five-Game-Changer deck at a Bracket 2 table isn't fun for anyone. Ask your group first.

Precon or Build: Who Should Pick Which?

Buy a precon if:

  • It's your first Commander deck. Start with what EDH is and how Commander works.
  • You want to play at your store's Commander night this week.
  • Your group plays at Bracket 2.
  • A precon commander already appeals to you.

Buy a precon and upgrade it if:

  • You like the precon's commander but find the deck clunky after a few games.
  • You want the most power per dollar.

Build from scratch if:

  • The commander you want has no precon.
  • Your group plays at Bracket 3 or 4.
  • You enjoy deckbuilding as much as playing, or you already own most of the staples.

Not sure you'll like a commander at all? Brawl on MTG Arena uses the same 100-card, singleton deckbuilding, so you can try a deck there before you buy paper cards.

The Bottom Line

For a first deck, buy a precon: about $30 to $46 gets you a finished 100 cards worth more than the box, and about $56 gets you sleeved and boxed. Build from scratch only when the commander you want has no precon or your table plays above Bracket 2, and expect EDHREC's average deck to cost several times a precon.

For most players the best value is the middle road: a precon plus $25 to $50 of targeted upgrades. Every deck's current price is in our Commander precon tracker, updated as prices move.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

All guides