TableTopMeta Logo

Jaws Secret Lair: Every Card, Prices & the Jaws MTG Card

The Jaws Secret Lair cost $39.99 in October 2025 and sells for $217.43 sealed on 13 Nov 2026. All 6 cards, the new Jaws MTG card at $162.47, and legality.

Shon Atsil8 min readMagic
Five Jaws Secret Lair cards fanned out on a dark purple background: the Jaws, Relentless Predator movie-poster card in the centre, with You're Gonna Need a Bigger Boat, Sneak Attack, Panic on Amity Island and Reckless Endeavor around it, all painted by Stephen Andrade

The Short Answer

Secret Lair x Jaws: Terror of Amity Island is a six-card Magic drop built around a new card, Jaws, Relentless Predator. Wizards of the Coast sold it on 13 October 2025 in the Secret Scare Superdrop, two per customer and in limited quantities, for $39.99 non-foil or $49.99 rainbow foil.

On 13 November 2026 the sealed drop trades at $217.43 non-foil and $309.11 rainbow foil on TCGplayer, 5.4 and 6.2 times its price. The Jaws card alone sells for $162.47, three quarters of the sealed price, and it has never been printed anywhere else.

A Secret Lair is a limited Magic: The Gathering product that Wizards sells directly on its own store, usually a handful of cards with new art, often from a film, game or band. Most are reprints of existing cards. Jaws is different: one of its six cards is brand new to Magic, and that card is why the drop costs what it does. For how the store, the queue and shipping work, see our MTG Secret Lair guide.

This page covers every card in the drop and its finish, what the Jaws card does and where it is legal, what each card and the sealed drop sell for now, and whether to buy sealed or singles.

What cards are in the Jaws Secret Lair?

Six cards, all painted by Stephen Andrade: one new card, four reprints and a Blood token. Wizards listed the contents in its Secret Scare Superdrop announcement, and the drop came in non-foil or rainbow foil.

SLD no.CardNew or reprintOriginal cardNon-foil, 13 Nov 2026Rainbow foil
2175Jaws, Relentless PredatorNew to Magic—$162.47$191.04
2176Panic on Amity IslandReprintDescent into Avernus$18.05$17.91
2178Sneak AttackReprintSneak Attack$16.84$14.66
2177Reckless EndeavorReprintReckless Endeavor$14.04$14.04
2180Blood tokenToken—$12.20$16.67
2179You're Gonna Need a Bigger BoatReprintAbrade$9.66$10.36
6 singles$233.26$264.68
Sealed drop$217.43$309.11
Launch price$39.99$49.99

TCGplayer market prices on 13 November 2026. The five cards are borderless and the Blood token is full art; Jaws is a mythic with a full-art frame made to look like the film poster (Scryfall). Two cards carry Jaws names in place of their own, "Panic on Amity Island" and "You're Gonna Need a Bigger Boat"; their original names are printed under the title. Sneak Attack's flavor text is "Da-Dum Da-Dum", and Reckless Endeavor's is Quint's "Bad fish… This shark? Swallow ya whole."

The bonus card: Cathartic Reunion

Scryfall lists a seventh Andrade card from the same superdrop as a Secret Lair bonus card: Cathartic Reunion (SLD 7045), in non-foil and rainbow foil, with the flavor text "BRODY: I used to hate the water. HOOPER: I can't imagine why." It is cheap: $2.31 non-foil and $2.29 rainbow foil on 13 November 2026. We found no Wizards source that says how it was handed out, so don't pay extra for a sealed drop sold "with bonus".

What does the Jaws MTG card do?

Jaws, Relentless Predator is a five-mana 5/5 legendary Shark with trample and haste. It costs {3}{R}{R}. Its two abilities, as Scryfall prints them:

  • "Whenever Jaws deals combat damage to a player, create that many Blood tokens." A Blood token is an artifact you can pay {1}, tap, discard a card and sacrifice to draw a card.
  • "Whenever a noncreature artifact is sacrificed or destroyed, Jaws deals 1 damage to each opponent."

The drop is built around those lines. Panic on Amity Island (Descent into Avernus) and Reckless Endeavor both make Treasure tokens, and every Treasure or Blood token you sacrifice is a noncreature artifact, so each one makes Jaws deal 1 damage to each opponent. The second ability counts any player's artifacts, not only yours. Sneak Attack puts Jaws onto the battlefield for one red mana, and You're Gonna Need a Bigger Boat (Abrade) can destroy an artifact.

Yes. Scryfall lists Jaws, Relentless Predator as legal in Commander, Legacy, Vintage and Oathbreaker, and not legal in Standard, Pioneer, Modern or Pauper. That is the usual rule for a card that is new to Magic in a Secret Lair: it is legal only in the eternal formats. It is a legendary creature, so it can lead a mono-red Commander deck. For what Commander is, see what is EDH.

The four reprints follow the legality of their original cards (Scryfall, 13 November 2026):

CardCommanderLegacyModernPioneerStandard
Jaws, Relentless PredatorLegalLegalNoNoNo
Panic on Amity Island (Descent into Avernus)LegalLegalNoNoNo
Reckless EndeavorLegalLegalNoNoNo
Sneak AttackLegalLegalNoNoNo
You're Gonna Need a Bigger Boat (Abrade)LegalLegalLegalLegalLegal

The Blood token is a token, not a card you can put in a deck. Descent into Avernus comes from Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate and Reckless Endeavor from Forgotten Realms Commander, Commander-focused sets that were never legal in Modern.

Will Jaws, Relentless Predator be reprinted?

Wizards said in its October 2025 announcement that a Universes Within version, the same rules under a name that isn't from the film, "will appear in a future Magic release". As of 13 November 2026 Scryfall lists no card other than Secret Lair 2175 with Jaws's rules text. Wizards also said this drop would not be available through WPN stores. So for now the only Jaws, Relentless Predator is the Secret Lair one.

How much is the Jaws Secret Lair worth now?

$217.43 non-foil and $309.11 rainbow foil at TCGplayer market price on 13 November 2026: 5.4 times the $39.99 non-foil price and 6.2 times the $49.99 rainbow foil price.

EditionLaunch, 13 Oct 20251 Nov 202613 Nov 2026ListingsLowest listing
Non-foil$39.99$238.64$217.437$222.82
Rainbow foil$49.99—$309.1119$279.04

The non-foil price has slipped $21.21 since our Secret Lair guide priced it on 1 November 2026, but the cheapest of its 7 listings is still above the market price. With so few listings, one or two sales move the figure.

How the Jaws card's price climbed

The drop's price is mostly the Jaws card's price. MTGRocks reported copies selling for about $42 in mid-November 2025, a month after the sale, and about $124 on average in February 2026, when it called Jaws "the most expensive mechanically unique Universes Beyond MTG card". It put the rise down to scarcity, as supply dwindled, and to recent cEDH (competitive Commander) results. Our hub had it at $169.39 on 1 November 2026; on 13 November 2026 it is $162.47 non-foil and $191.04 rainbow foil.

26 Sep 2025

StarCityGames reports the full Secret Scare Superdrop, including Jaws at $39.99 non-foil and $49.99 foil.

13 Oct 2025

The superdrop goes on sale "in limited quantities" (Wizards). The Jaws store page limits it to two per customer.

Mid-Nov 2025

The Jaws card sells for about $42 (MTGRocks).

Feb 2026

The Jaws card averages about $124 (MTGRocks, 8 February 2026).

13 Nov 2026

Jaws card $162.47; sealed drop $217.43 non-foil and $309.11 rainbow foil (TCGplayer).

Jaws Secret Lair: sealed or singles?

For the non-foil drop, sealed is cheaper; for rainbow foil, the singles are. The six non-foil singles add up to $233.26, so the sealed drop at $217.43 saves you $15.83. In rainbow foil it flips: the six singles cost $264.68 and the sealed drop $309.11, $44.43 more.

Edition6 singlesSealedDifference
Non-foil$233.26$217.43Singles $15.83 more
Rainbow foil$264.68$309.11Sealed $44.43 more

TCGplayer market prices, 13 November 2026, without the Cathartic Reunion bonus card.

Take Jaws out and the drop is ordinary. The other five non-foil cards add up to $70.79, and three of them have cheaper printings: Descent into Avernus from $8.20, Sneak Attack from $9.81 and Abrade from $0.18 (Scryfall, 13 November 2026). Reckless Endeavor's cheapest printing is $11.26, close to the Jaws version's $14.04.

If you want…Do this (prices 13 Nov 2026)
To play Jaws in CommanderBuy the single: $162.47 non-foil. There is no cheaper printing
The whole drop for the shelfNon-foil sealed at $217.43, which is $15.83 less than its six singles
Rainbow foilBuy the singles you want; the sealed rainbow drop costs $44.43 more than all six
The other cards to playBuy cheaper printings of Sneak Attack, Descent into Avernus and Abrade
An investmentBe careful: it is already 5.4 times its price, has 7 non-foil listings, and a Universes Within version of Jaws has been promised

Where to buy the Jaws Secret Lair now

Only second-hand. Wizards sold it in limited quantities, two per customer, and said it would not go to WPN stores. On 13 November 2026 TCGplayer has 7 non-foil listings from $222.82 and 19 rainbow foil listings from $279.04. The Gonna Need a Bigger Boat Everything Bundle, the superdrop's every-drop bundle named after the film's line, has no listings and no market price on TCGplayer on the same date.

The other Secret Scare Superdrop drops

Jaws was one of the drops Wizards sold on 13 October 2025 in the Secret Scare Superdrop. The three Furby drops from the same sale are priced card by card in our Furby Secret Lair guide, the two Iron Maiden drops in our Iron Maiden Secret Lair guide, and Dwight's Destiny in our Office Secret Lair guide. Each $199 spent on the superdrop added one rainbow foil Cryptic Command promo while supplies lasted (Wizards; StarCityGames called it a traditional foil).

More Secret Lair guides

Selling a Jaws card? Our guide to where to sell MTG cards compares the fees.

Citations & Resources

Frequently Asked Questions