Quick verdict
To connive, you draw a card, then discard a card. If the card you discarded was not a land, the creature that connived gets a +1/+1 counter. Connive X means draw X, discard X, and one counter for each nonland card discarded. Nobody can respond in the middle of it, and a creature that has left the battlefield still connives; it just can't get the counter. Ledger Shredder and Raffine, Scheming Seer are the best connive cards.
Connive in MTG is a keyword action: when a creature connives, you draw a card, then discard a card, and if the card you discarded was a nonland card you put a +1/+1 counter on that creature. In short, connive is a loot that grows the creature whenever you throw away a spell instead of a land.
Connive came from Streets of New Capenna (29 April 2022), where it was the mechanic of the Obscura, the white-blue-black crime family. Wizards' launch article put it this way: connive improves both "creature strength and hand quality". It has since come back in Modern Horizons 3, Marvel's Spider-Man and Marvel Super Heroes (plus one Transformers card), and Scryfall lists 50 paper cards with it on 19 November 2026 (51 counting an Alchemy card).
What Does Connive Do? The Rules
The reminder text on Ledger Shredder is the whole mechanic:
Whenever a player casts their second spell each turn, this creature connives. (Draw a card, then discard a card. If you discarded a nonland card, put a +1/+1 counter on this creature.)
The Comprehensive Rules (rule 701.50) spell it out in a few short steps:
- Draw a card. The creature's controller draws.
- Discard a card. Any card from your hand, including the one you just drew.
- Check what you discarded. A nonland card means one +1/+1 counter on the conniving creature. A land means no counter.
A few details follow from that wording.
It's your choice what to discard. You can throw away an extra land to keep your spells, or discard a spell to grow the creature. Late in the game, when lands are dead draws, connive becomes card filtering and a counter at the same time.
Nobody can respond in the middle. Once an ability that makes a creature connive starts to resolve, no player can take actions until it is done. An opponent can't see you discard a nonland card and then kill the creature before the counter lands.
No discard, no counter. If you discard nothing (most likely because your hand is empty and an effect stops you drawing), the creature gets no counter.
It is a draw and a discard. Conniving counts for anything that cares about drawing, such as Kang, Temporal Tyrant's "second card each turn" trigger, and for anything that cares about discarding, such as madness or Archfiend of Ifnir.
Double-faced cards use the front face. In the graveyard a double-faced card has only its front face's characteristics (rule 712.6a). A modal double-faced card with a spell on the front and a land on the back counts as a nonland card, so it earns the counter.
| Situation | What happens |
|---|---|
| You discard a nonland card | One +1/+1 counter on the conniving creature |
| You discard a land | No counter, but you still drew and filtered |
| The creature left the battlefield first | You still draw and discard; no counter; 'when it connives' triggers still fire |
| Several creatures connive at once | They connive one at a time, in the order their controller chooses |
| Connive X | Draw X, discard X, one counter per nonland card discarded |
| Connive 0 | Nothing happens and 'whenever connives' abilities don't trigger |
| You can't draw and your hand is empty | Nothing to discard, so no counter |
Conniving With a Creature That Left the Battlefield
This is the ruling people ask about most. If a spell or ability tells a specific creature to connive, but that creature has already left the battlefield, the creature still connives. The game uses its last known information to work out which creature connived and who controlled it (rule 701.50b).
You draw and discard as normal. If you discard a nonland card, the +1/+1 counter has nowhere to go, so it isn't placed. Abilities that trigger "when [that creature] connives" still trigger.
Psychic Pickpocket is the clean example. It reads: "When this creature enters, it connives. When it connives this way, return up to one target nonland permanent to its owner's hand." If your opponent kills the Pickpocket in response to the enter trigger, you still draw, discard and bounce a permanent. You only lose the counter. The target for the bounce is chosen after the Pickpocket connives, so you know what you drew before you pick.
The same is true of Obscura Interceptor, whose connive trigger returns a spell to its owner's hand. Killing it in response doesn't stop the bounce.
Connive X (Connive N)
The rules call the variant connive N (rule 701.50d); the cards print it as "connives X". To connive X, you draw X cards, then discard X cards, then put one +1/+1 counter on the creature for each nonland card you discarded.
It isn't a later addition. It was in Streets of New Capenna from the start, on Raffine, Scheming Seer, and three cards use it on 19 November 2026:
- Raffine, Scheming Seer: whenever you attack, target attacking creature connives X, where X is the number of attacking creatures.
- Mask of the Schemer (New Capenna Commander): the equipped creature connives X after dealing combat damage to a player, where X is the damage dealt.
- Spymaster's Vault (Modern Horizons 3): a land that, for {B} and {T}, has a creature you control connive X, where X is the number of creatures that died this turn.
If X is 0, no connive happens at all (rule 701.50e). Spymaster's Vault on a turn where nothing died does nothing, and abilities that trigger whenever a creature connives won't trigger.
When Several Creatures Connive at Once
Change of Plans tells X creatures to connive at the same time. They don't do it simultaneously: they connive one at a time, and you choose the order (rule 701.50c uses APNAP order if more than one player controls conniving creatures). That matters because each draw can change what you want to discard next.
With Change of Plans you also choose which creatures phase out only after all of them have connived.
Best Connive Cards
Prices below are Scryfall's on 19 November 2026 for the default printing.
Ledger Shredder
- How it connives
- Whenever any player casts their second spell each turn
- Set
- Streets of New Capenna
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $8.71
1U
Cost
Raffine, Scheming Seer
- How it connives
- Whenever you attack, an attacker connives X (X = attackers)
- Set
- Streets of New Capenna
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $9.00
WUB
Cost
Change of Plans
- How it connives
- X of your creatures connive, then any of them can phase out
- Set
- New Capenna Commander
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $12.51
X1U
Cost
Norman Osborn // Green Goblin
- How it connives
- Unblockable; connives on combat damage to a player
- Set
- Marvel's Spider-Man
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $9.94
1U
Cost
Spymaster's Vault
- How it connives
- B, T: connive X, X = creatures that died this turn
- Set
- Modern Horizons 3
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $3.22
Land
Cost
M.O.D.O.K.
- How it connives
- Pay 3 life: connives, on your turn
- Set
- Marvel Super Heroes
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $4.19
3BB
Cost
Body Launderer
- How it connives
- Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies
- Set
- Streets of New Capenna
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $1.35
2BB
Cost
Mask of the Schemer
- How it connives
- Equipped creature connives X after combat damage
- Set
- New Capenna Commander
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $1.81
2U
Cost
Lethal Scheme
- How it connives
- Removal; each creature that convoked it connives
- Set
- New Capenna Commander
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $0.29
2BB
Cost
Psychic Pickpocket
- How it connives
- Connives on entering, then bounces a nonland permanent
- Set
- Streets of New Capenna
- Price (19 Nov 2026)
- $0.22
4U
Cost
Ledger Shredder. A two-mana 1/3 flyer that connives whenever any player casts their second spell in a turn, so it grows on your opponents' turns too. Spells cast before it entered count, so if Shredder was your first spell, your next one triggers it. It is the highest-ranked connive card on EDHREC (rank 846) and is legal in Pioneer and Modern.
Raffine, Scheming Seer. The Obscura boss: a three-mana 1/4 flyer with ward {1}. Attack with three creatures and one of them draws three, discards three and can grow by three. On EDHREC it leads 10,549 Commander decks on 19 November 2026, and those decks lean into reanimation: Reanimate (67%) and Animate Dead (57%) are among their top cards, because connive is a free way to put a big creature in the graveyard. A 2026 reprint in The Zeta Set starts at $3.22.
Change of Plans. An instant that has as many creatures as you like connive, then phases any of them out to dodge a board wipe or removal. It only appeared in New Capenna Commander, which is why it is the most expensive card here.
Norman Osborn. The Marvel's Spider-Man front face is a two-mana unblockable creature that connives every time it hits a player, then transforms into Green Goblin, which gives the nonland cards in your graveyard mayhem. Conniving is how you stock that graveyard.
Spymaster's Vault. A land that does nothing until creatures die, then turns a sacrifice turn into a big draw. It takes no spell slot, so it fits any black deck that sacrifices creatures.
Body Launderer and Lethal Scheme. Body Launderer connives each time another nontoken creature of yours dies and reanimates on its own death. Lethal Scheme is instant-speed removal with convoke, and every creature you tapped to convoke it connives.
Connive Payoffs
A few cards reward the act of conniving itself, not just the cards it draws. The first three trigger on "whenever a creature you control connives", so they fire even if the creature gets no counter:
- Ultron, Unlimited ({1}{U}{B}): connives when it attacks, and each time a creature you control connives you may pay {1} for a 2/2 Robot Villain token.
- Iron Monger, Sadistic Tycoon ({2}{B}): each connive puts a +1/+1 counter on every Villain you control.
- Glorious Purpose ({1}{U}): each connive puts an extra +1/+1 counter on the creature and a plan counter on the enchantment. At six plan counters you exile your top four and cast any number of the spells free.
- Leader, Super-Genius ({2}{U}{U}): a replacement effect. Each time a creature you control would connive, you first draw an extra card, then it connives. It also has a creature connive at the start of your combat.
Outside those, connive works with any card that cares about discarding: madness cards, flashback and reanimation targets (see our flashback guide), and Toluz, Clever Conductor, which exiles your discards and gives them back when it dies.
Common Misconceptions
"Connive is a keyword ability." It is a keyword action, like scry, surveil and explore. Cards tell a creature to connive; creatures don't "have" connive.
"Killing the creature in response stops the connive." It doesn't. You still draw and discard, and "when it connives" triggers still happen. Only the counter is lost.
"Discarding a land is a waste." It gives no counter, but it improves your hand. Pitching extra lands late in the game is the point of the mechanic.
"Connive X means one counter." You get one counter for each nonland card discarded, up to X.
"Opponents can kill it after I discard a spell." They can't act until the connive has finished, so the counter is already there.
Where Connive Fits
Connive sits in the same family as the other card-selection keyword actions: surveil and scry look at the top of your library, and explore is the closest relative, also trading a card's type for a +1/+1 counter. The Doom Prevails deck in our Marvel Commander decks guide is built around connive and discard, and the MTG keywords glossary covers every other mechanic you'll meet.
Most of the original connive cards were opened from Streets of New Capenna boxes. A set booster box sells for $182.01 (TCGplayer market price, 18 November 2026) on TCGplayer today, and our New Capenna set booster box tracker shows what the cards inside are worth against that price.
Citations & Resources
- Wizards of the Coast: Comprehensive Rules, rule 701.50 (Connive)
- Wizards of the Coast: Streets of New Capenna mechanics
- Scryfall: Every card with connive
- Scryfall: Ledger Shredder and the connive rulings
- EDHREC: Raffine, Scheming Seer
Related Guides
- The Ultimate MTG Keywords Glossary — every keyword, with a printable cheat sheet
- What Explore Means in MTG — the other keyword action that hands out +1/+1 counters
- What Surveil Means in MTG — card selection without the draw
- MTG Flashback Explained — a reason to want spells in your graveyard
- MTG Stack Explained — why nobody can respond in the middle of a connive
- Marvel Commander Decks — the Doctor Doom deck built on connive

