Best MTG Booster Box to Buy Right Now, Ranked by EV (2026)

The best MTG booster box to buy, ranked by EV: every current Play and Collector box by card value per dollar, with net EV and the odds a box beats its price.

Shon Atsil9 min readMagic
Best MTG booster box to buy: the chase cards of the top three boxes by EV, Special Guests Chrome Mox from Aetherdrift and Victimize from Murders at Karlov Manor, and the Star Trek Stardates Sheoldred, the Apocalypse

Our top 4 picks

Ranked. Pick one to read why, and what it costs.

  1. Top pick
    1

    Murders at Karlov Manor Play Booster Box

    The best box for card value: $1.95 of cards per $1

    ~$125TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  2. 2

    Aetherdrift Play Booster Box

    The best Standard-legal box on value

    ~$102TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  3. 3

    Star Trek Play Booster Box

    The newest set, level with Aetherdrift at $1.60 per $1

    ~$105TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  4. 4

    Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster Box

    The most dollars of cards over the price of any current box

    ~$303TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

Sealed products

  1. Murders at Karlov Manor Play Booster BoxTop pick

    Murders at Karlov Manor Play Booster Box

    The best box for card value: $1.95 of cards per $1

    • Pro: $242.28 of cards for a $124.24 box on 18 Nov 2026
    • Pro: 36 packs, and over 99% of 10,000 simulated boxes beat the price
    • Pro: A seller keeps $104.04 on average, the closest of any box to its price
    • Con: Leaves Standard at the 2027 rotation

    Price

    ~$125TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  2. Aetherdrift Play Booster Box

    Aetherdrift Play Booster Box

    The best Standard-legal box on value

    • Pro: $163.80 of cards for a $102.16 box on 18 Nov 2026, $1.60 per $1
    • Pro: Special Guests Chrome Mox is its top pull
    • Con: A seller keeps only 46% of the price: most of its value is bulk

    Price

    ~$102TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  3. Star Trek Play Booster Box

    Star Trek Play Booster Box

    The newest set, level with Aetherdrift at $1.60 per $1

    • Pro: $174.60 of cards for a $108.95 box on 18 Nov 2026
    • Pro: Stardates reprints such as Sheoldred, the Apocalypse
    • Con: Five days after release: new-set prices move most in the first weeks

    Price

    ~$105TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

  4. Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster Box

    Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster Box

    The most dollars of cards over the price of any current box

    • Pro: $462.24 of cards for a $303.75 box on 18 Nov 2026, $158.49 over
    • Pro: A seller keeps 75% of the price, second only to Murders at Karlov Manor
    • Con: The most expensive box on this list; not a Standard set

    Price

    ~$303TCGplayer market, 19 November 2026

The Short Answer

The best MTG booster box to buy for value is Murders at Karlov Manor Play. On 18 November 2026 an average box held $242.28 of cards for a $124.24 TCGplayer price: $1.95 of cards for every $1. Over 99% of 10,000 simulated boxes beat that price. Aetherdrift and Star Trek came next at $1.60.

19 of the 20 Play Booster boxes we track held more in cards than their price; The Hobbit was the one that didn't. None of the 41 Collector Booster boxes that pass our coverage rule did. No box pays back its price if you sell the cards, so this is a ranking of boxes to open, not to flip. A Murders at Karlov Manor box costs $124.68 (TCGplayer market price, 19 November 2026) today.

Every figure comes from TableTopMeta's own EV calculator, which prices each box daily. Our MTG booster box guide covers pack counts and which box suits drafting, gifts or new players. This page does one thing: ranks every current box on its numbers.

The 10 best MTG booster boxes to buy, ranked by EV

These are the current Play Booster boxes, from Murders at Karlov Manor (February 2024) to Star Trek (13 November 2026). Play Boosters replaced Draft and Set Boosters in 2024, so older Draft boxes are leftover stock with a collectors' price and are left out here. Three of them, March of the Machine (1.57), Streets of New Capenna (1.44) and the first Modern Horizons (1.43), would have made this list.

#BoxEVPrice usedRatioNet EVSimulated boxes beating price
1Murders at Karlov Manor (36 packs)$242.28$124.241.95$104.04over 99%
2Aetherdrift$163.80$102.161.60$47.40over 99%
3Star Trek$174.60$108.951.60$63.60over 99%
4Foundations (36 packs)$263.16$168.351.56$91.08over 99%
5Modern Horizons 3 (36 packs)$462.24$303.751.52$228.24over 99%
6Outlaws of Thunder Junction (36 packs)$286.20$189.201.51$119.1699%
7Lorwyn Eclipsed$155.70$105.501.48$54.0098%
8Avatar: The Last Airbender$182.10$124.291.47$61.8098%
9Marvel Super Heroes$144.60$100.681.44$42.0098%
10Marvel's Spider-Man$157.80$110.691.43$44.7097%

TableTopMeta EV and TCGplayer market prices, 18 November 2026. Boxes hold 30 packs unless marked.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles just missed at 1.41. Here is what each of the top ten costs today, cheapest first:

TCGplayer market prices, updated daily. Last update 19 November 2026. The buy buttons are affiliate links.

1. Murders at Karlov Manor: the best value by a distance

No other current box comes close: 22% more card value per dollar than second place, and it has topped the Play boxes in every weekly record since 18 October 2026. It is a 36-pack box selling near the price of 30-pack ones, and its value is spread across the packs rather than resting on one chase card: the wildcard slot alone carries about a third of it. The rare big hits are Special Guests reprints such as Victimize, $25.69 on Scryfall on 19 November 2026 (its $89.35 foil comes only in Collector Boosters). The catch for Standard players: it is one of six sets that leave Standard at the 29 January 2027 rotation, a week before Nauctis releases on 5 February (see our 2027 rotation guide). Outlaws of Thunder Junction, sixth here, leaves with it.

Aetherdrift edges Star Trek by a fraction of a cent per dollar. Aetherdrift's top pull is the Special Guests Chrome Mox ($163.88 on Scryfall on 19 November 2026; its $218.42 foil comes only in Collector Boosters). Star Trek's is a Stardates reprint of Sheoldred, the Apocalypse (the Khan, Engineered Evil card, $63.53; its $127.90 foil is also a Collector Booster card); Stardates cards replace a common in about 1 in 25 packs. Star Trek's figures are five days after release (our Star Trek guide has the set), and a new set's prices move most in its first weeks. On 16 November its ratio was 1.58.

4–10

Foundations stays in Standard until at least 2029, per Wizards. Modern Horizons 3 is the expensive box that still earns its price; it is a Modern and Commander set, not Standard. Lorwyn Eclipsed and the three Universes Beyond boxes after it were all priced around $100 to $125 on 18 November and beat their price in 97% or more of simulated boxes.

Best for opening vs best for value

The ratio answers "how much card value do I get per dollar?" That is the right question if you keep the cards, draft with them or build decks. It is the wrong one if you plan to sell, because most of a box is bulk. Three different questions give three different leaders:

If you wantBest box (18 Nov 2026)Why
The most card value per dollarMurders at Karlov Manor$1.95 of cards per $1
The most dollars of cards over the priceModern Horizons 3$158.49 more in cards than the box cost
The least lost if you sell everythingMurders at Karlov ManorA seller keeps $104.04 of $124.24 (84%); 26% of simulated boxes pay back if sold

Net EV reorders the list. After Murders at Karlov Manor, Modern Horizons 3 keeps 75% of its price for a seller and Outlaws of Thunder Junction 63%. Aetherdrift, second on ratio, keeps only 46%, because so much of its value is in cards worth too little to list. At the bottom, a Hobbit Play box keeps 28%.

That is the honest answer to "can I make money opening boxes": on average, no. No box we track had a net EV above its price on 18 November 2026.

The 5 Collector Booster boxes closest to their price

Collector boxes are built around foils, borderless and serialized cards, and you pay for that. Of the 41 Collector boxes that pass our coverage rule, none held more in cards than its price on 18 November 2026. These five came closest:

#BoxEVPrice usedRatioNet EVSimulated boxes beating price
1The Hobbit Collector$505.32$543.780.93$350.0423%
2Avatar: The Last Airbender Collector$443.76$480.620.92$275.2815%
3Star Trek Collector$349.20$382.280.91$207.2423%
4Marvel Super Heroes Collector$386.76$431.880.90$231.2422%
5Tarkir: Dragonstorm Collector$413.76$512.040.81$266.2819%

TableTopMeta EV and TCGplayer market prices, 18 November 2026. 12 packs per box.

TCGplayer market prices, updated daily. Last update 19 November 2026. The buy buttons are affiliate links.

One thing Collector boxes do better: they hold fewer bulk cards, so a seller keeps more. The Hobbit Collector box keeps 64% of its price for a seller and pays back if sold in 9% of simulated boxes; the Hobbit Play box does so in 0.15%. Whether the Hobbit boxes are worth it at all is in our Hobbit booster box breakdown, and why Collector boxes trail Play boxes in every set is in Collector Booster vs Play Booster.

The 5 worst MTG booster boxes to buy for value

These are the bottom five current Play boxes. They aren't bad boxes to open for fun, but each gives you less card value per dollar than the boxes above.

BoxEVPrice usedRatioNet EVSimulated boxes beating price
The Hobbit$129.90$132.970.98$36.9040%
Innistrad Remastered (36 packs)$305.28$291.681.05$104.4060%
Final Fantasy$269.40$254.631.06$118.5052%
Secrets of Strixhaven$163.20$143.541.14$44.7071%
Tarkir: Dragonstorm$192.30$158.511.21$72.6073%

18 November 2026.

The Hobbit is the only current Play box worth less in cards than its price. Final Fantasy and Innistrad Remastered are the expensive ones that barely clear theirs: 40% to 48% of simulated boxes come in under the price. Among Collector boxes the gap is far wider: on 18 November The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Collector held $663.96 of cards against a $2,037.14 price (0.33), and Bloomburrow Collector $514.08 against $1,346.63 (0.38).

Reality Fracture, the newest set outside Universes Beyond, sat in the middle at 1.35. Our Reality Fracture box EV analysis breaks it down.

Three things the ranking can't tell you

EV is an average, not your box. Much of a box's value sits in a few chase cards, so most boxes land under the average and a few land far above it. The "simulated boxes beating price" column is the better guide to what one box does; each box page lets you open one card by card.

Prices move. A box ranked third today can be eighth next week. The tables of prices above update daily; the EV figures are dated. If you are waiting for a sale, our MTG Black Friday guide shows what a real discount on each box looks like.

A sealed box is not an investment. A sealed box is worth what the next buyer pays, and the ratio here says nothing about where that will go.

Collecting Pokémon too? The same method, card prices weighted by pull rates against the box's TCGplayer price, ranks Pokémon booster boxes on our Pokémon EV calculator.

On 18 November 2026, Murders at Karlov Manor Play gave the most card value per dollar, Aetherdrift and Star Trek were the best boxes that stay in Standard, and Modern Horizons 3 left the most dollars of cards over its price. No Collector box that passes our coverage rule beat its price.

Before you buy, open a few simulated boxes on the EV calculator and check what a real Black Friday deal on your box looks like in our MTG Black Friday guide.


Citations & Resources

  • EV, net EV, simulated-box shares and price coverage from TableTopMeta's EV calculator, snapshot of 18 November 2026: 223 boxes tracked, 203 with a market price, 192 passing the 95% coverage rule
  • Weekly EV and box-price history from the EV calculator's history file, 18 October to 16 November 2026
  • Booster box market prices from TCGplayer (via the tcgcsv.com mirror), 18 November 2026; the price tables above refresh daily
  • Card prices for Victimize (Special Guests), Chrome Mox (Special Guests) and Sheoldred, the Apocalypse (Stardates) from Scryfall, 19 November 2026
  • Selling fees: TCGplayer Marketplace commission 10.75% from 10 February 2026, TCGplayer Seller Blog
  • Sets leaving Standard with Nauctis: Banned and Restricted Announcement, Wizards of the Coast, 12 October 2026
  • Foundations legal in Standard until at least 2029: Collecting Foundations, Wizards of the Coast

Frequently Asked Questions