Best Pirate Commanders in MTG (2026), Ranked

Edward Kenway leads the most pirate decks on EDHREC (1,240). 12 pirate commanders ranked, plus the $47 Ahoy Mateys precon and budget picks (19 Nov 2026).

Shon Atsil19 min readMagic
Best pirate commanders in MTG: Edward Kenway in the centre, fanned with Admiral Brass, Unsinkable, Captain N'ghathrod, Admiral Beckett Brass and Captain Howler, Sea Scourge on a dark background

Our top 5 picks

Ranked. Pick one to read why, and what it costs.

  1. Top pick
    1

    Edward Kenway

    Best pirate commander: the most decks tagged Pirates, with a Treasure and Vehicle engine

    $8.37Scryfall, 19 November 2026

  2. 2

    Admiral Beckett Brass

    Best budget pirate commander: a Pirate lord that steals permanents

    $0.26Scryfall, 19 November 2026

  3. 3

    The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander Deck: Ahoy Mateys

    The pirate precon: Admiral Brass, Unsinkable, with 35 Pirates and 11 legendary ones

    $47.27TCGplayer market, 17 November 2026

  4. 4

    Captain N'ghathrod

    The most-built legendary Pirate, for a Horror mill deck rather than a pirate deck

    $13.48Scryfall, 19 November 2026

  5. 5

    Captain Howler, Sea Scourge

    Cheap and popular blue-red discard deck led by a Shark Pirate

    $0.33Scryfall, 19 November 2026

Our picks

  1. Edward KenwayTop pick

    Edward Kenway

    Best pirate commander: the most decks tagged Pirates, with a Treasure and Vehicle engine

    • Pro: 1,240 of its 13,076 EDHREC decks are tagged Pirates, the most of any commander
    • Pro: 19 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates, 14 of them $0.40 or less
    • Con: $8.37, the second most expensive of the top eight; not in any precon

    Price

    $8.37Scryfall, 19 November 2026

  2. Admiral Beckett Brass

    Admiral Beckett Brass

    Best budget pirate commander: a Pirate lord that steals permanents

    • Pro: $0.26, and 25 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates
    • Pro: Played in 8,459 Edward Kenway decks and 6,728 Admiral Brass decks too
    • Con: Its steal needs three Pirates to connect with the same player in one turn

    Price

    $0.26Scryfall, 19 November 2026

  3. The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander Deck: Ahoy Mateys

    The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander Deck: Ahoy Mateys

    The pirate precon: Admiral Brass, Unsinkable, with 35 Pirates and 11 legendary ones

    • Pro: $47.27 sealed for $89.19 of cards (1.89×)
    • Pro: Includes Don Andres, Admiral Beckett Brass, and Breeches and Malcolm, a popular partner pair
    • Con: Its one pricey card, Black Market Connections ($15.82), is 18% of the card value

    Price

    $47.27TCGplayer market, 17 November 2026

  4. Captain N'ghathrod

    Captain N'ghathrod

    The most-built legendary Pirate, for a Horror mill deck rather than a pirate deck

    • Pro: Leads 18,979 EDHREC decks, rank #91
    • Con: Only 7 decks tagged Pirates; none of its 30 most-played nonland cards is a Pirate
    • Con: $13.48, the most expensive of the top eight

    Price

    $13.48Scryfall, 19 November 2026

  5. Captain Howler, Sea Scourge

    Captain Howler, Sea Scourge

    Cheap and popular blue-red discard deck led by a Shark Pirate

    • Pro: Leads 12,553 EDHREC decks (rank #185) for $0.33
    • Con: A discard deck first: 1,284 decks tagged Discard, 130 tagged Pirates

    Price

    $0.33Scryfall, 19 November 2026

The Short Answer

Edward Kenway is the best pirate commander. It leads 13,076 decks on EDHREC (19 November 2026), rank #176 of all commanders, and 1,240 of them are tagged Pirates, more than any other commander. It costs $8.37 on Scryfall.

Captain N'ghathrod has more decks (18,979) and is a Pirate, but it leads Horror mill decks: only 7 are tagged Pirates. The budget pick is Admiral Beckett Brass at $0.26, a Pirate lord whose 30 most-played nonland cards include 25 Pirates.

The pirate precon is Ahoy Mateys (2023), led by Admiral Brass, Unsinkable: $47.27 sealed for $89.19 of cards, with 35 Pirates in the deck.

Pirate decks in Commander are mostly blue, black and red: creatures that make Treasure, steal opponents' cards and creatures when they connect, and lords that pump the rest of the crew. This page ranks every pirate commander by how many people have built it on EDHREC, explains what the top eight do, lists the cards most of their decks run, and shows which ones actually lead pirate decks. For how typal decks work in general, see our MTG tribal decks guide.

The Best Pirate Commanders, Ranked

  • 1.Captain N'ghathrod

    Colours
    Blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    18,979 (#91)
    Tagged Pirates
    7
    What it does
    Horrors mill on hit; steals a milled artifact or creature each end step

    $13.48

  • 2.Edward Kenway

    Colours
    Blue-black-red
    EDHREC decks
    13,076 (#176)
    Tagged Pirates
    1,240
    What it does
    Treasure for each tapped Pirate or Vehicle; Vehicles steal cards

    $8.37

  • 3.Captain Howler, Sea Scourge

    Colours
    Blue-red
    EDHREC decks
    12,553 (#185)
    Tagged Pirates
    130
    What it does
    Discarding pumps a creature that draws when it connects

    $0.33

  • 4.Xavier Sal, Infested Captain

    Colours
    Black-green-blue
    EDHREC decks
    8,095 (#345)
    Tagged Pirates
    12
    What it does
    Taps to populate or proliferate

    $1.32

  • 5.Admiral Brass, Unsinkable

    Colours
    Blue-black-red
    EDHREC decks
    7,923 (#354)
    Tagged Pirates
    872
    What it does
    Returns a Pirate from your graveyard as a 4/4 each turn

    $0.25

  • 6.Don Andres, the Renegade

    Colours
    Blue-black-red
    EDHREC decks
    6,866 (#437)
    Tagged Pirates
    346
    What it does
    Stolen creatures get +2/+2; stolen spells make Treasure

    $0.44

  • 7.Admiral Beckett Brass

    Colours
    Blue-black-red
    EDHREC decks
    4,784 (#646)
    Tagged Pirates
    540
    What it does
    Pirate lord; steals a permanent after three Pirates connect

    $0.26

  • 8.Breeches, Brazen Plunderer + Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator

    Colours
    Blue-red
    EDHREC decks
    3,990 (#733)
    Tagged Pirates
    340
    What it does
    Partners: Pirate damage makes Treasure and exiles cards to play

    $0.43 (both)

  • 9.Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer

    Colours
    Red
    EDHREC decks
    3,064 (#883)
    Tagged Pirates
    11
    What it does
    One-mana Treasure maker that casts opponents' cards

    $37.19

  • 10.Francisco, Fowl Marauder + Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator

    Colours
    Blue-black
    EDHREC decks
    2,639 (#979)
    Tagged Pirates
    272
    What it does
    Partners: Pirate damage makes Treasure and explores

    $0.51 (both)

  • 11.Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel

    Colours
    Blue
    EDHREC decks
    1,724 (#1,283)
    Tagged Pirates
    1
    What it does
    Flash flyer that loots, then casts discards for free

    $2.20

  • 12.Breeches, the Blastmaker

    Colours
    Blue-red
    EDHREC decks
    1,342 (#1,475)
    Tagged Pirates
    7
    What it does
    Second spell each turn: flip a coin to copy it or deal damage

    $0.31

How to read it. EDHREC decks is the number of decks EDHREC lists for that commander (or partner pair) on 19 November 2026, with its rank among all commanders in brackets. Tagged Pirates is how many of those decks EDHREC tags with the Pirates theme. Price is the cheapest English non-foil paper printing on Scryfall on 19 November 2026.

The Tagged Pirates column shows which commanders lead pirate decks: Edward Kenway (1,240), Admiral Brass, Unsinkable (872), Admiral Beckett Brass (540), Don Andres (346), Breeches and Malcolm (340) and Francisco and Malcolm (272). Captain N'ghathrod, Xavier Sal, Ragavan, Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel and Breeches, the Blastmaker are Pirates whose decks are about something else.

Best Pirate Tribal Commander: Edward Kenway

If you searched for a pirate tribal (typal) deck, these are the commanders whose decks are mostly Pirates:

Edward KenwayAdmiral Brass, UnsinkableAdmiral Beckett BrassBreeches + Malcolm
EDHREC decks (19 Nov 2026)13,076 (#176)7,923 (#354)4,784 (#646)3,990 (#733)
Decks tagged Pirates1,240872540340
Pirates among top 30 nonland cards19212521
ColoursBlue-black-redBlue-black-redBlue-black-redBlue-red
Price (Scryfall)$8.37$0.25$0.26$0.43 for both

Edward Kenway is the best pick for most players. It has the most decks tagged Pirates, and its Treasure ability counts every tapped Pirate you control. Its decks also run Vehicles (1,186 tagged Vehicles), and five Vehicles are among its 30 most-played nonland cards. Admiral Beckett Brass leads the most Pirate-heavy deck (25 of its top 30 cards) and is the cheapest. Admiral Brass, Unsinkable comes in the Ahoy Mateys precon, with most of the pirate staples.


1. Captain N'ghathrod

Cost: {3}{U}{B}, 3/6 legendary Horror Pirate EDHREC: 18,979 decks, rank #91 (19 November 2026) Price: $13.48 for the extended-art Battle for Baldur's Gate printing, the cheapest non-foil; the regular printing only comes in foil ($12.11), and the foil-etched one is $4.71 (Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. Your Horrors have menace. Whenever a Horror you control deals combat damage to a player, that player mills that many cards. At the beginning of your end step, you put an artifact or creature card that an opponent milled from their library this turn onto the battlefield under your control.

Who it suits: mill players who like using their opponents' creatures. It is a Pirate, but its decks aren't: the top tags are Mill (2,348), Horrors (1,551) and Theft (572), only 7 decks are tagged Pirates, and none of its 30 most-played nonland cards is a Pirate.

Key cards in Captain N'ghathrod decks:

  • Consuming Aberration ($0.38): in 18,002 of 18,979 decks. Each spell you cast mills every opponent down to their next land, and it grows with their graveyards.
  • Nemesis of Reason ($2.96): in 15,812. Mills ten cards whenever it attacks.
  • Mindcrank ($13.00): in 15,645. Opponents mill a card for each life they lose.
  • Grazilaxx, Illithid Scholar ($1.62): in 15,143.
  • Fractured Sanity ($2.56): in 14,364. Each opponent mills fourteen.

Cheapest way in: a single ($13.48 non-foil, or $4.71 foil-etched). Captain N'ghathrod leads the Mind Flayarrrs precon (Battle for Baldur's Gate, 10 June 2022), but that deck sold for $296.73 on TCGplayer on 18 November 2026. It also has a Secret Lair printing ($18.91) from the Iron Maiden Secret Lair.


2. Edward Kenway

Cost: {2}{U}{B}{R}, 5/5 legendary Human Assassin Pirate EDHREC: 13,076 decks, rank #176 (19 November 2026) Price: $8.37 (Assassin's Creed, Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. At the beginning of your end step, you create a Treasure token for each tapped Assassin, Pirate and Vehicle you control, so a full attack pays you back in mana. Whenever a Vehicle you control deals combat damage to a player, you exile the top card of their library face down, and you may play it for as long as it stays exiled.

Who it suits: anyone who wants an actual pirate deck. EDHREC's top tags for it are Pirates (1,240), Vehicles (1,186), Treasure (1,044) and Theft (401), and 19 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates. It came out in the Assassin's Creed set on 5 July 2024; see our Assassin's Creed collector's guide for that set.

Key cards in Edward Kenway decks:

  • Adéwalé, Breaker of Chains ($0.25): in 11,516 of 13,076 decks. Digs six cards deep for an Assassin, Pirate or Vehicle when it enters.
  • The Indomitable ($3.63): in 11,239. A 6/6 trampling Vehicle that draws a card whenever one of your creatures hits a player.
  • Jackdaw ($0.35): in 11,017. A Vehicle that can discard your hand to draw a card for each artifact you control.
  • The Belligerent ($0.31): in 10,209. A Vehicle that makes Treasure and lets you play cards off the top of your library.
  • Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator ($0.27): in 10,189. A Treasure for each opponent your Pirates damage.

Cheapest way in: the $8.37 single. Edward Kenway isn't in any of the 206 Commander decks in MTGJSON's deck list, but four of the five key cards above cost under $0.40.


3. Captain Howler, Sea Scourge

Cost: {2}{U}{R}, 5/4 legendary Shark Pirate with ward ({2}, pay 2 life) EDHREC: 12,553 decks, rank #185 (19 November 2026) Price: $0.33 (Aetherdrift, Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. Whenever you discard one or more cards, a target creature gets +2/+0 for each card discarded, and whenever that creature deals combat damage to a player this turn, you draw a card. Loot, wheel and cycle, then swing with one big creature.

Who it suits: blue-red players who like card draw and discard. Its top tags are Discard (1,284), Wheels (455), Aggro (417) and Cycling (327); 130 decks are tagged Pirates and 5 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates.

Key cards in Captain Howler decks:

  • Faithless Looting ($0.43): in 10,311 of 12,553 decks. Draw two, discard two, with flashback.
  • Frantic Search ($0.40): in 9,896.
  • Marauding Mako ($0.39): in 9,272. A one-mana Shark Pirate that gets a +1/+1 counter for each card you discard.
  • Ghostly Pilferer ($2.09): in 9,198.
  • Magmakin Artillerist ($0.32): in 8,775. An Elemental Pirate that deals damage to each opponent for each card you discard.

Cheapest way in: a $0.33 single. Captain Howler is from the main Aetherdrift set, not a Commander deck.


4. Xavier Sal, Infested Captain

Cost: {B}{G}{U}, 3/3 legendary Human Fungus Pirate EDHREC: 8,095 decks, rank #345 (19 November 2026) Price: $1.32 for the extended-art printing, $1.53 for the regular one (The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander, Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. Two sorcery-speed tap abilities: remove a counter from another permanent you control to populate (copy a creature token you control), or sacrifice another creature to proliferate.

Who it suits: counters and tokens players. Its top tags are Tokens (493), Planeswalkers (300), +1/+1 Counters (297) and Proliferate (241); only 12 decks are tagged Pirates and none of its 30 most-played nonland cards is a Pirate.

Key cards in Xavier Sal decks:

  • Kiora's Follower ($0.36): in 4,331 of 8,095 decks. Untaps Xavier Sal so you can use it twice.
  • Ezuri, Stalker of Spheres ($0.52): in 4,015. Draws a card whenever you proliferate.
  • Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominus ($2.10): in 3,989. Doubles proliferate.
  • Evolution Sage ($3.03): in 3,706. Proliferates on every land drop.
  • Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler ($3.37): in 3,347. Lets Xavier Sal tap the turn it comes down.

Cheapest way in: a $1.32 single. It isn't in any of the 206 Commander decks in MTGJSON's deck list.


5. Admiral Brass, Unsinkable

Cost: {2}{U}{B}{R}, 3/3 legendary Human Pirate EDHREC: 7,923 decks, rank #354 (19 November 2026) Price: $0.25 (The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander, Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. When Admiral Brass enters, you mill four cards. At the beginning of combat on your turn, you may return a Pirate creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield with a finality counter. It has base power and toughness 4/4 and haste that turn, and if it would die, it's exiled instead. One dead Pirate comes back each turn, and each can come back only once.

Who it suits: players who want the precon's pirate deck. Its top tags are Pirates (872), Treasure (507) and Reanimator (464), and 21 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates.

Key cards in Admiral Brass decks:

  • Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator ($0.27): in 7,400 of 7,923 decks.
  • Hostage Taker ($0.36): in 7,075. Exiles a creature or artifact, and you can cast it.
  • Coercive Recruiter ($0.30): in 7,063. Steals a creature for the turn whenever a Pirate enters, and Admiral Brass brings one back every combat.
  • Port Razer ($3.11): in 7,008. An extra combat phase when it connects.
  • Skeleton Crew ($0.29): in 6,902. Pumps your Pirates and makes a 2/2 Skeleton Pirate whenever creature cards leave your graveyard.

Cheapest way in: the Ahoy Mateys precon, which Admiral Brass leads and which has all five of those cards ($47.27, see below). The single is $0.25.


6. Don Andres, the Renegade

Cost: {1}{U}{B}{R}, 4/3 legendary Vampire Pirate EDHREC: 6,866 decks, rank #437 (19 November 2026) Price: $0.44 (The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander, Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. Each creature you control but don't own gets +2/+2, menace and deathtouch, and becomes a Pirate. Whenever you cast a noncreature spell you don't own, you create two tapped Treasure tokens.

Who it suits: players who like stealing. Its top tags are Theft (701), Pirates (346) and Treasure (320), and 10 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates. Our best vampire commanders ranking covers its other creature type.

Key cards in Don Andres decks:

  • Hostage Taker ($0.36): in 5,456 of 6,866 decks.
  • Ramirez DePietro, Pillager ($0.20): in 5,339. Exiles the top card of a player's library whenever your Pirates hit them, and you can cast it.
  • Laughing Jasper Flint ($0.38): in 4,798.
  • Breeches, Brazen Plunderer ($0.16): in 4,645.
  • Thief of Sanity ($0.71): in 4,535.

Cheapest way in: a $0.44 single. Don Andres is also in Ahoy Mateys.


7. Admiral Beckett Brass

Cost: {1}{U}{B}{R}, 3/3 legendary Human Pirate EDHREC: 4,784 decks, rank #646 (19 November 2026) Price: $0.26 (The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander, Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What it does. Your other Pirates get +1/+1. At the beginning of your end step, you gain control of a nonland permanent controlled by a player who was dealt combat damage by three or more Pirates this turn.

Who it suits: budget pirate players. Its top tags are Pirates (540), Treasure (359) and Theft (279), and 25 of its 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates, the most of any commander here. It is played far more in the 99 than as a commander: it is in 8,459 Edward Kenway decks and 6,728 Admiral Brass decks.

Key cards in Admiral Beckett Brass decks:

  • Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator ($0.27): in 4,014 of 4,784 decks.
  • Hostage Taker ($0.36): in 3,924.
  • Coercive Recruiter ($0.30): in 3,774.
  • Corsair Captain ($0.19): in 3,746. A second Pirate lord that makes a Treasure when it enters.
  • Captain Lannery Storm ($0.33): in 3,528. Makes a Treasure every time it attacks.

Cheapest way in: a $0.26 single; all five of those cards are in Ahoy Mateys, and each costs under $0.40.


8. Breeches, Brazen Plunderer and Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator

Cost: {3}{R}, 3/3 legendary Goblin Pirate with menace, and {2}{U}, 2/2 legendary Siren Pirate with flying EDHREC: 3,990 decks as a pair, rank #733 (19 November 2026) Price: $0.16 and $0.27 (Scryfall, 19 November 2026)

What they do. Both have Partner, so you can run them as two commanders. Whenever one or more of your Pirates deal damage to your opponents, Malcolm makes a Treasure for each opponent dealt damage, and Breeches exiles the top card of each of those opponents' libraries. You can play those cards that turn, spending mana as though it were any colour.

Who it suits: players who want a cheap blue-red pirate deck. Their top tags are Pirates (340), Treasure (245) and Combo (123), and 21 of their 30 most-played nonland cards are Pirates. Breeches is also a Goblin; see our best goblin commanders.

Key cards in Breeches and Malcolm decks:

  • Siren Stormtamer ($0.40): in 3,054 of 3,990 decks. Sacrifices to counter a spell that targets you or your creatures.
  • Lightning-Rig Crew ($0.29): in 2,828. Pings each opponent, and untaps whenever you cast a Pirate spell.
  • Spectral Sailor ($0.28): in 2,636. A one-mana flash flyer.
  • Breeches, Eager Pillager ($0.77): in 2,539.
  • Coercive Recruiter ($0.30): in 2,476.

Cheapest way in: $0.43 for the two singles. Both are also in Ahoy Mateys.


The Other Four, Briefly

  • Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer (3,064 decks, $37.19): a one-mana 2/1 with dash. Whenever it deals combat damage to a player, you create a Treasure and exile the top card of their library, and you may cast it this turn. Its decks are Treasure (198) and Aggro (103) decks, and expensive ones: Xorn ($14.40), Ruby Medallion ($14.83) and Goldspan Dragon ($11.25) are each in more than half of them.
  • Francisco, Fowl Marauder and Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator (2,639 decks, $0.51 for both): blue-black partners. Francisco is a 0/1 flying Bird Pirate that can't block and explores whenever your Pirates deal damage to a player (see explore). Pirates (272) and Combo (121) are their top tags.
  • Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel (1,724 decks, $2.20): a two-mana flash flyer. Each time it hits a player it gets a chorus counter and you draw and discard; from the fourth counter on, you may cast the discarded card for free. Its decks are Extra Turns (57) and Control (32) decks, with no Pirates among their top 30 cards.
  • Breeches, the Blastmaker (1,342 decks, $0.31): a blue-red Goblin Pirate. Whenever you cast your second spell each turn, you may sacrifice an artifact and flip a coin: win and you copy the spell, lose and Breeches deals damage equal to its mana value. Treasure (70) and Artifacts (69) are its top tags.

Pirate commanders outside the top 12

Two more lead real pirate decks: Mary Read and Anne Bonny (1,312 decks, $0.50, 112 tagged Pirates), a hasty looter that makes a Treasure whenever you discard an Island, Pirate or Vehicle, and Captain Storm, Cosmium Raider (1,214 decks, $0.21, 119 tagged Pirates), which puts a +1/+1 counter on a Pirate whenever an artifact enters under your control.

The other legendary Pirates with EDHREC pages (not counting the partners, which are built in pairs) are Zara, Renegade Recruiter (629), Malcolm, the Eyes (529), Ramirez DePietro, Pillager (491), Captain Ripley Vance (472), Adéwalé, Breaker of Chains (289), Captain Vargus Wrath (212), Jhoira, Weatherlight Corsair (206), Captain Lannery Storm (186), Breeches, Eager Pillager (138), Kari Zev, Skyship Raider (72) and Ramirez DePietro (68). Several of them are played far more in other pirate decks than at the helm: Captain Lannery Storm is in 8,590 Edward Kenway decks.

Three commanders mention Pirates without being one. Vaan, Street Thief (1,364 decks) rewards Scouts, Pirates and Rogues that connect, Baral and Kari Zev (883) can make a Monkey Pirate token called First Mate Ragavan, and The Indomitable (744) is a Vehicle. We left them out of the ranking because they aren't Pirates.


Best Budget Pirate Commander

Admiral Beckett Brass at $0.26 leads the most Pirate-heavy deck of any commander here. Admiral Brass, Unsinkable is $0.25, Captain Howler $0.33, and the Breeches and Malcolm partner pair $0.43 for both.

Most of the Pirates that pirate decks share are cheap, and all eight below are in the Ahoy Mateys precon. Scryfall prices on 19 November 2026, with the number of Admiral Brass decks (of 7,923) that run each:

CardPriceAdmiral Brass decksWhat it adds
Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator$0.277,400Treasure when your Pirates deal damage
Hostage Taker$0.367,075Exiles a creature or artifact you can cast
Coercive Recruiter$0.307,063Steals a creature whenever a Pirate enters
Skeleton Crew$0.296,902Pirate lord and Skeleton Pirate tokens
Corsair Captain$0.196,885Pirate lord and a Treasure
Siren Stormtamer$0.406,584Protects you and your creatures
Captain Lannery Storm$0.336,421A Treasure every attack
Merchant Raiders$0.236,335Locks down a creature when a Pirate enters

Those eight add up to $2.37. The expensive cards in these decks are Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer ($37.19, in 2,235 Admiral Brass decks), Black Market Connections ($15.34, in 5,121), Glint-Horn Buccaneer ($6.81), Kindred Discovery ($6.10), Pitiless Plunderer ($3.96, in 4,895) and Port Razer ($3.11, in 7,008).

Is There a Pirate Precon?

Yes: Ahoy Mateys, a Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander deck released on 17 November 2023 and led by Admiral Brass, Unsinkable. We checked all 206 paper Commander decks in MTGJSON's deck list, up to the Star Trek decks of November 2026, and it is the only one built around Pirates: 35 Pirates counting the commander, 11 of them legendary. Those include Don Andres, Admiral Beckett Brass, Breeches, Brazen Plunderer, Malcolm, Keen-Eyed Navigator, Francisco, Fowl Marauder and Captain Lannery Storm, so the deck covers four of the top eight entries on this list.

It is worth its price. On 17 November 2026 it sold for $47.27 (TCGplayer market), and its 100 cards were worth $89.19, or $64.06 counting only cards worth $1 or more. The most valuable were Black Market Connections ($15.82), Shared Animosity ($5.93) and Herald's Horn ($5.79). It has no Game Changers.

The cards Admiral Brass players most often add that aren't in the precon (Scryfall prices, 19 November 2026): Breeches, Eager Pillager ($0.77, in 5,449 of 7,923 decks), Forerunner of the Coalition ($0.79, in 4,717), Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel ($2.20, in 4,408), Mary Read and Anne Bonny ($0.50, in 3,872) and Kitesail Larcenist ($0.65, in 3,865).

One other precon has a Pirate as its face commander: Mind Flayarrrs (Battle for Baldur's Gate, 10 June 2022), led by Captain N'ghathrod. It is a Horror mill deck with no other Pirates, and it sold for $296.73 on 18 November 2026. For every Commander precon since 2023 and what it sells for, see our Commander precon price table.

What Makes a Good Pirate Deck

  • Blue, red and black. Scryfall lists 173 paper cards with the Pirate type on 19 November 2026: 91 are blue, 69 red, 43 black and 2 green (multicoloured cards count once per colour). Four of the top seven commanders here are blue-black-red.
  • Treasure. Edward Kenway, Malcolm, Corsair Captain and Captain Lannery Storm all make Treasure, which pays for the four- and five-mana Pirates and the cards you steal.
  • Stealing. Hostage Taker, Coercive Recruiter, Breeches, Brazen Plunderer and Admiral Beckett Brass take opponents' creatures, cards or permanents, and Don Andres makes stolen creatures bigger.
  • Lords. Admiral Beckett Brass, Corsair Captain and Skeleton Crew each give your other Pirates +1/+1.
  • Damage triggers. Most pirate payoffs need a Pirate to connect, so evasive Pirates such as Malcolm, Spectral Sailor and Warkite Marauder ($0.27, in 5,681 Admiral Brass decks) carry the others' triggers.

Are any pirate commanders Game Changers?

No. We checked the 28 legendary Pirates against Scryfall's Game Changer flag and the Game Changers list: none is on it, and none of the 173 Pirate cards is either. Ahoy Mateys and Mind Flayarrrs have no Game Changers. Only Ragavan has one among its 25 most-included cards, but many popular pirate decks add them, which raises their bracket. On EDHREC on 19 November 2026:

  • Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer: Jeska's Will in 1,553 of 3,064 decks (51%), Gamble in 1,132 (37%) and The One Ring in 656 (21%).
  • Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel: Cyclonic Rift in 512 of 1,724 (30%), Fierce Guardianship in 506 (29%) and Rhystic Study in 487 (28%).
  • Francisco and Malcolm: Fierce Guardianship in 729 of 2,639 (28%) and Demonic Tutor in 704 (27%).
  • Captain N'ghathrod: Rhystic Study in 4,738 of 18,979 (25%), Cyclonic Rift in 4,441 (23%) and Demonic Tutor in 3,285 (17%).
  • Edward Kenway: Cyclonic Rift in 2,357 of 13,076 (18%) and Rhystic Study in 1,800 (14%).
  • Breeches and Malcolm: Cyclonic Rift in 685 of 3,990 (17%) and Jeska's Will in 623 (16%).
  • Admiral Beckett Brass: Cyclonic Rift in 772 of 4,784 (16%).
  • Captain Howler: Gamble in 1,993 of 12,553 (16%).
  • Don Andres: Rhystic Study in 960 of 6,866 (14%) and Opposition Agent in 926 (13%).
  • Admiral Brass, Unsinkable: Cyclonic Rift in 979 of 7,923 (12%).

If you are new to brackets and power levels, start with what EDH means and how Commander works.

Conclusion: Edward Kenway Leads the Crew, Ahoy Mateys Is the Cheap Way In

Captain N'ghathrod is the Pirate most people build, with 18,979 EDHREC decks, but those are Horror mill decks. For a deck full of Pirates, Edward Kenway is the pick: 13,076 decks, 1,240 of them tagged Pirates, and a Treasure engine that rewards every Pirate you attack with.

On a budget, Admiral Beckett Brass at $0.26 leads the most Pirate-heavy deck, and the eight Pirates most decks share cost $2.37 together. The easiest start is the Ahoy Mateys precon: $47.27 for $89.19 of cards, Admiral Brass at the helm and four of this list's top eight commanders inside. For other tribes, see our MTG tribal decks guide.


Citations & Resources


Frequently Asked Questions